A Canadian BANANA Bus Tour of the Marcellus Shale (Un Tour de Bus À LA BANANE canadien de Marcellus Shale)
![]()
Rachael Colley
Nicole Jacobs
EID Marcellus Team Members
It’s no secret the world is watching what happens in the Northern Tier of Pennsylvania when it comes to natural gas development. We were reminded of this just last week when Marcellus Drilling News announced that a group from Quebec were making the trek to our region to see Marcellus Shale activity first-hand. It seemed a bit odd for a group to be making such a long journey without contacting any companies developing the Marcellus Shale. Most groups would want to contact natural gas producers to receive a tour of a natural gas rig, compressor station or hydraulic fracturing operation if they actually wanted to learn about the process of extracting natural gas. Given the odd set of circumstances, we figured we’d head out to see just what kind of experience the group was seeking and what they came to see.
First Stop: Cortland, New York?
If you were going to take a tour of “Gasland” where would your first stop be? If you’re up on natural gas related topics, you’d probably say somewhere in Bradford, Tioga, Susquehanna or Lycoming Counties. Why? These counties have seen the most natural gas activity and as a result receive significant media attention.
Knowing this, one can imagine our confusion when the Quebec group made their first stop in Cortland, New York. Here attendees were provided a presentation on “the agricultural impacts of Marcellus Shale development” by the Gas Drilling Awareness of Cortland County (GDACC) . Logically, this makes little sense given the fact there is no Marcellus development occurring in New York. This little fact could make it difficult for residents in Cortland to speak intelligently about “impacts” from natural gas development. Nonetheless, Rachael joined the group with an open mind, thinking maybe, just maybe, GDACC had some good information to present.
Sadly, Rachel was confronted with the truth when a man registering attendees asked for her position on natural gas development before allowing her to enter the room. Why this would matter is a bit baffling, but apparently it was important to the GDACC folks. Rachael responded that she was there to learn about the agricultural impacts of hydraulic fracturing. She was promptly told to watch the movie Gasland because it would explain everything. This fellow must have missed the memo explaining the film has been debunked numerous times and Josh Fox himself has admitted to omitting key information if it didn’t conform to his agenda. But, we digress.
Once inside the meeting, Rachael was approached by a woman who asked who she was, where she was from and how she heard about the meeting. For whatever reason, they wanted to be sure no one in favor of natural gas development entered that room.
Once admitted Rachel could finally watch the presentation which showcased acres of farmland being plowed around natural gas wells. For Rachael, who is from New York and has seen her neighbors struggle to keep their farms afloat, the images were initially promising. How could that be? Well, they illustrate how a farmer could be getting royalties and still be able to farm in close vicinity to a well site. For many farmers a natural gas well means finally having the opportunity to catch a financial break while continuing their farming unimpeded! That’s why the NY State Farm Bureau supports natural gas development and has asked Governor Cuomo (D) to speed his review of the state’s regulatory documents. But, of course, this was not the message the group wanted these visitors to take with them so none of this was mentioned.
Where others might finally see hope of saving a family farm, GDACC tried hard to create lasting images of devastation by showing photos of natural gas rigs alongside a typical Finger Lakes landscape. What they didn’t mention was that the well site only looks that way for less than one month while its being developed. Later in the process, when the well is reclaimed only a 1.5 acre footprint will remain. For most farmers 1.5 acres of land is a rounding error left off a surveying map.
GDACC also failed to mention the difficult financial times befalling the people of New York , especially farmers. Overall, this presentation was not only inaccurate, but laced with fear mongering and a complete misrepresentation of a situation that no one in that room was actually qualified to speak to.
Onward to Bradford County
The next day showed promise, though, as the group headed to Bradford County where many companies are actually developing natural gas from the Marcellus Shale. Nicole caught up with the group as they headed to the Riverstone Inn for lunch and a presentation by Mike Lovegreen, the manager of the Bradford County Conservation District.
For those not familiar with Towanda, the Riverstone Inn now has a renovated restaurant and two hotels thanks to natural gas development. Greg Murelle, Manager of the Riverstone, was happy to host the group and hoped they would also see the economic impacts the County has witnessed thanks to this new industry. Greg, of course, has experienced those impacts first-hand and talked about them in this video:
http://youtu.be/2jcBBGfJl8Y
During his presentation Lovegreen discussed a variety of topics including the amount of money companies have spent repairing roads and naturally occurring methane in area water supplies. He also highlighted the economic progression of Bradford County thanks to natural gas development. Once a severely economically depressed area, Bradford County now boasts one of the lowest unemployment rates in the state and is one of two Pennsylvania counties with the highest wage growth over the past year. All of this is due to responsible development of the Marcellus Shale and you can see it here ( including the French translations in the clips below).
[myyoutubeplaylist lvc0OlAtT8E, bVYkbBmKw3g, 12MfbpwAOoA]
As you can see from the videos, the conservation district manager has quite a different impression from the information the group received in New York. It’s amazing the difference in perception between those actually living in a natural gas area (Pennsylvania) and those not (Quebec and New York). It is also worth noting the message Mike delivered to the group didn’t seem to register based on what the travelers reported when they got home. Be sure to check out their quotes to the press below and ask yourself how they could have missed so much and, at the same time, saw so much that just wasn’t so.
Upon returning from a trip to Pennsylvania to study shale gas, a delegation from the Saint Lawrence Valley is more opposed than ever to developing the resource in Quebec. Smog, animal infertility, potable water contamination, food insecurity, property value depreciation, tanker traffic – all this in return for a small compensation and a few jobs. Serge Fortier of the Saint Lawrence Valley umbrella group against shale gas is convinced of the need for a moratorium. The trip also gave PQ MNA Martine Ouellet a lot of ammunition. She says the government is wrong to have placed so much emphasis on gas projects in the recent budget. Quebec Solidaire’s future candidate in Bertheir, Louise Beaudry, says that the shale gas industry did not keep its promise in Pennsylvania.
We saw things that were overwhelming
Saint-Maurice farmer Jean Guilbert has come back devastated from his recent trip to Pennsylvania. This trip took place just a few days after Marcel Cote from Secor told the Chamber of commerce and industries in Trois Rivieres that nuclear energy and shale gas were good business opportunities for the province. Jean Guilbert deplored the effects of shale gas development: water and air pollution, impact on animal and human health, and the irresponsibility of companies. He said that the idea of shale gas being a good business opportunity is an illusion of progress because the gains for the population are minimal and very short-term and the bulk of the money earned will go into the pockets of financial holdings. Jean Guilbert says he has returned more determined than ever to sensitize people to the dangers of shale gas development.
Shale gas: Quebec citizens return worried from Pennsylvania
Quebec citizens came back worried from their trip to Pennsylvania, where they had gone to study the impact of shale gas development on farming. What they heard is that farmers in Pennsylvania were suffering from devastating effects, such as a high animal mortality rate, problems with gestation, and health problems. Farmers had said they even had to negotiate the right of passage on their own lands because of the presence of gas pipelines. Farmers in Pennsylvania also warned the visitors not to sign contracts with shale gas companies back home without consulting a lawyer. They say they had been duped and they regret the contracts they signed. A third delegation from Quebec might visit Pennsylvania in June.
Following Mike Lovegreen’s presentation, the group proceeded to a tour with well-known Bradford County BANANA (Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything) activist Dianne Siegmund. Dianne’s last “tour” resulted in one participant proclaiming chemical genocide is occurring in the region.
“This is the worst thing that can happen,” [Toshia] Hance said. “It’s chemical genocide. These people are ultimately dying due to the radiation contamination.”
Unfortunately, Dianne’s degree in psychology and status of “holding down the fort largely by herself down there,” (see below) does not make her an expert on anything related to natural gas development and, frankly, the information she shares tends to be misleading and wholly inaccurate. She is alone in her efforts to disparage natural gas development in the county, largely because the vast majority of Bradford County residents are pleased with the development and many are even working in the industry. Following is a great example of Dianne’s tendency to wildly exaggerate and overstate in how she reportedly explains natural gas activities on her tours (from a July, 2011, e-mail circulating among anti-natural gas supporters):
First: A group of us went down to Bradford County, PA yesterday to see the devastation for ourselves. And devastation is what we did see and learn about. I will be writing up a talking-point report on this soon. For the moment, our guide was Dianne Siegmund …. She is holding down the fort largely by herself down there (for instance almost single-handedly so far documenting 92 poisoned wells in the county, including one woman whose body is radioactive from drinking her well water, fighting her way through an intimidated populace who can’t talk, because they have signed non-disclosure deals –or won’t talk because they are afraid that the energy companies will literally cut off the fresh water that is being delivered to them.) She and Mike Bastion … who also accompanied us, are virtually devoting their lives now to getting the word out and helping to prevent fracking from getting a hold here in NYS. They beg us please to organize more trips, get more people down there to see what they have to show us and hear what they have to tell us. Let’s keep them in the loop and organize as many trips as we can. Seeing is definitely believing — smelling (the truck diesel,) hearing (the deafening pipeline pumping stations,) choking (on the clouds of dust on the roads,) coughing, and wiping stinging eyes (from air pollution as bad as that of Los Angeles,) and dodging (the endless monster trucks barreling by) is also believing. – Dianne Siegmund
Many of the examples Diane used last year have since been investigated and the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) found the items to be naturally occurring incidents not related to natural gas development. On this trip there wasn’t any dust on the roads and the only smell Nicole came across was some pretty foul manure a farmer was spreading across his field.
Commissioner Doug McLinko, who was willing but unable to speak to the group, regrets they didn’t take the time to talk with more community leaders. He opined on that point in his remarks below:
“Bradford County has had tremendous positive impacts from this industry. Our residents are working, our roads are being fixed, and we desperately needed what this industry has provided. Have there been some issues, sure. But those are few and far between. I just hope these individuals from Quebec were given an accurate portrayal of our county and the opinions of its residents.” – Bradford County Commissioner Doug McLinko
It Wouldn’t be a Tour Without a Stop in Dimock
The group ended their excursion with a tour of Carter Road in Dimock where they met with the litigants there. We’re sure they weren’t told of the EPA’s recent findings that Dimock’s water is safe, nor did they take the time to talk with the majority of residents in the community represented by Dimock Proud. If they had done this, they would have received a much different story than the one they likely recieved.
Interestingly, the only welcome signs seen in Dimock were put up by Dimock Proud who hoped the international visitors would take the time to meet with them to get a more complete, and accurate, view of Dimock.
After the weekend’s events we left hoping the group had a pleasant visit even if the majority of the information they received was inaccurate. If the group wants to understand the real situation in communities developing shale resources they should come back and take a tour of a natural gas rig or other natural gas infrastructure. Or, at the very least, speak with community leaders and other residents of the real “Gasland” – the ones who are delighted to live here and have natural gas supporting their previously faltering economy. If the group does come back and meet with these folks they will find the real truth. You know, the truth New York fractivists don’t want to let out of the bag. That truth is that natural gas has been good to Pennsylvania and it will good to Quebec as well. Le gaz naturel a été bon à Pennsylvanie et il ira faire bon à Québec aussi.


Pingback:Canadian Bus Tour Folks More Interested in Narrative Than Facts - US Message Board - Political Discussion Forum
Posted at 16:37h, 27 March[…] Canadian Bus Tour Folks More Interested in Narrative Than Facts A group of Canadians toured upstate New York and PA over the weekend and they seemed to be more interested in confirming an anti-gas narrative than learning the real facts. A Canadian BANANA Bus Tour of the Marcellus Shale | Energy In Depth – Northeast Marcellus Init… […]
Bill
Posted at 18:33h, 27 MarchThe people coming from Canada wanted to see the effects of Nat Gas drilling for themselves without a pro gas company planting their propaganda in their minds.this is why they came !
Tom
Posted at 21:04h, 27 MarchI see. So, what I say is propaganda and what you say is something else. OK, Bill let’s get real here.
Farmer Wheezer
Posted at 23:43h, 27 March*cough*
PA_Cannuck
Posted at 11:41h, 28 MarchIf they really wanted to see the effects of Natural Gas Drilling, would it not have made sense to visit a drill site, to see an actual fracturing operation, to talk to the people who have actually leased their land and had wells drilled on it, to talk to the local mayors?
This trip was obviously nothing more than a group of activists searching for more fuel to stoke their fire, and not looking to learn the real story.
Bill talks about peoples lives/health/quality of life…
… What is the alternative? I guess he supports more deep sea drilling, or drilling in the Arctic – maybe he prefers we send more money and or troops over to the middle east? We all know that long term will be wind/solar/renewables, but we are no where near that point yet. You have a chance to become self sufficient, keeping your Canadian Dollars in Canada. Don’t you think that will improve the quality of life of all Canadians? Exporting gas to US and overseas… bringing in more money into Canada, and vastly reducing tax burden of Canadians.
What about the quality of life of those in drilling areas? Property values are going through the roof, a huge infrastructure (housing, hotels, restaurants, entertainment, etc, etc) is established, unemployment almost non-existent… how can you say quality of life is diminished?
People need to realize that Natural Gas IS the best environmental choice right now, less polluting than oil/coal/bio-fuel, hydroelectric etc. It’s not perfect but significantly better than all these alternatives.
Bill
Posted at 01:29h, 28 MarchYes what you say is pro gas promotion ,what I comment about is people’s lives,health,quality of life without pollution .Health and environment are so much more important then thinking about making a quick buck.Not you or any other Gas co PR will ever make the people that know this to be true, accept Nat gas drilling.I once lived in an area that is one of the most heavily polluted areas of the country and saw what it did and does to the health of the people there.I believe you on the other hand only have known the area you seem to take for granted .
Tom
Posted at 06:28h, 28 MarchNow you’re getting into “holier than thou” territory, Bill. And, all of sudden now you speak as an outsider after complaining that I identified you by your accent, which you yourself commented on at the hearing?
David Crea
Posted at 10:57h, 28 MarchThank you EID for exposing how so many ‘activists’ become ‘mis-educated’ and are then looked-at as some kind of ‘expert’ back in their hometowns, by fools who are too lazy to investigate themselves.
After hearing of the ‘devastation’ in Bradford County, I went to investigate, and drove-around for 3 hours looking for it, and could find nothing that qualified as ‘devastation’.
I did however observe one or two Trenton-Blackstone well pads, about 20 Marcellus Well pads in various states of completion, one well drill rig’s mast sticking up from the trees, one water pond, and two pipeline crossings being installed under roads. But the ROADS!?….all-new thick-asphalt high-speed ‘country’ roads that any district and all the native and formerly-starving farmers living nearby would be delighted to have!!!
Oh, and I did see some old farmhouses undergoing obvious renovations, and several Pole Barns for farm-equpment that were obviouisly newly-constructed — all indications of the beneficial monetary-results of Marcellus Gas Development.
Those proclaiming ‘DEVASTATION’ need to be nailed-down as to specific-details, locations, pictures and timing — which they will NOT be able to produce!
Bryant La Tourette
Posted at 00:02h, 29 MarchOnce again EID is proactive in flushing out the truth. We all know the industry is supporting EID to cover the stories doing their best to be transparent with information. The media has been milking the fear campaign for ratings. Who would of thought Industry exposing the truth.
Recently the Greedylandowners.com team was at a “informational” meeting put on by a local anti gas group . We asked them out right who backs them?… They avoided our question. Another greedy representative stood up and challenged the speaker’s information. The result …they called the cops!
Ask EID who backs them they will tell you ,the industry. Without calling the cops.. Ask Greedy who backs us, because even our side wants to know …Three independent landowners that could care less if we lease our land. We are sick of the lies. We travel this state and PA to find the facts….Ask an Anti group who backs them they avoid the question. We have the Park Foundation tax returns that show us who has received money for the anti misinformation campaign. We question the speakers if they received any money and the speakers look at us and say the are unbiased then take an anti gas stance a direct lie to the audience! I would trust the industry in a second based on the low level of honesty and deceitful message the anti campaign has spewed. Have you no shame even after Carter rd being exposed?. A citizen stood up and said to a speaker at one of the “informational “meeting in a church..First: Must I remind you, you are in a church..Then followed by, you people should be ashamed of yourself putting in half truths to manipulate with fear! Half the room cleared out! People have had it and see right through you.
When was the last time you heard Catskill Mountain Keepers start out by saying we are funded by the Anti Gas Agenda? Are you not proud of your sponsors?
I am not surprised the stories that came out of PA from the BUS TOUR nor are the people. But just like Carter Rd, give it time and the antis will find that NY and PA is where the end of the extreme environments movement went too far. THE FEAR MONGERING HAS PASSED THE PEEK OF THE BELL CURVE. Now you are pulling in the few shredded stragglers to circle the wagons to ban FRACKING in NY.Your last act. Your fate will be equal to Custard last stand. Like Custard last words to his Indian scout ” What do WE do now”? The Scout replied …WE? Your days are numbered and we can thank the EIDs team for the major part in exposing your bullying , shameful, shamful, outlandish, unethical, deceiving display.
Thanks to Tom and his team at EID and yes the Industry that backs them. They have done more for the landowners and all who wish to stop the mass exodus and rebuild our once great state now known as”the welfare state” with real revenue. The Anti propaganda campaign will make history but not for the right reasons. You will have damaged any legitimate groups for a long time. We will never let our children forget.. Our youth today are onto the main stream media and the socialism agenda. The squeaky wheel will not get oiled . They are learning its not the majority….Replace the Wheel…..
Victor Furman
Posted at 02:28h, 29 MarchLet’s burn manure some of this manure and keep the nitrates from flowing to the Chesapeake bay
Bill
Posted at 03:59h, 29 MarchTom first of all I refered to my living in a heavily polluted area as a reference (maybe you didn’t understand ) here’s something for you .This is Fracing what you see is silica sand dust which causes silicosis.This is being done everywhere they Frac. Take a look ( you probably don’t want your readers to see this ,but it is real .I got pictures…………… http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Ffeature%3Dplayer_detailpage%26v%3DAz84Vfa1eMY&h=nAQHnRN2PAQEchDN9G-7ly-DbbHZNSoWR22WsNh3sjvTo5A
Bill
Posted at 04:03h, 29 March@ David C I will nail down anything you want .Obviously your tour only showed you what you wanted to see…..here’s something for you ….http://www.facebook.com/l.php?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Ffeature%3Dplayer_detailpage%26v%3DAz84Vfa1eMY&h=nAQHnRN2PAQEchDN9G-7ly-DbbHZNSoWR22WsNh3sjvTo5A
Bill
Posted at 16:06h, 29 MarchAll you Pro Gas people think everything is lies .I guess this is what the pursuit of money does to a persons character .Have a ball people but the effort to regulate and even stop this destructive process is growing every day…….Believe what you want …
Vera
Posted at 10:35h, 31 MarchI was on the bus with the French Canadians on this tour and directed them to a site near Montrose and then we went to Franklin Forks to see the latest , families with bad water
impacted by WPX drilling and fracking and we never made it to Dimock.
GettheFacts
Posted at 16:37h, 31 MarchI wonder why they didn’t go to Dimock. Could it be because the puppets she helps to master are starting to cut their strings? She’s been riding on their coat tails for quite a while now. Now that her 15 min. of fame and their fame is almost gone what will she do?