Marcellus Shale

A Natural Gas Tour in Dimock, Pennsylvania

A good time was had by all recently at the Worcester Strawberry Festival on Main Street in Worcester, New York.  I convinced Dick Downey and Bruce Hollenbeck to take a break from our business of gathering  signatures for a pro-natural gas senate candidate, to wander up to the local anti-gas group display (we left Ed Zaengle to pick up our slack, a good day for Worcester signatures, our pro-gas candidate will officially be on the ballot).  We arrived to find the typical poster board propaganda, this time complete with a seismic map advertising the danger of fracturing presents to our hamlet’s back-up water supply (Caryl’s Lake). We had a discussion/debate that grew louder, drew an audience and presented us an opportunity we could not have planned any better!

By coincidence they were distributing copies of their latest fear rag “The No Frack Almanac.” This is the upper half of the front page.

No Frack Almanac

No Frack Almanac

We were already scheduled to visit “hell” (Susquehanna County) the following week along with Don Zaengle and a group from Dick’s Otego Coalition. Our first stop was the center of hell itself.

Elk Lake School District near Dimock, Pennsylvania

Elk Lake School District near Dimock, Pennsylvania

This well is several years old and is netting millions of dollars for the Elk Lake School District. We can report that even the most vulnerable amphibians in closest proximity to the wellhead were alive and thriving!

Elk Lake School District-Frog

Elk Lake School District-Frog

Frog at Elk Lake School District

Frog at Elk Lake School District

We traveled to an active well site, too.

Natural Gas Well, Dimock, Pennsylvania

Natural Gas Well, Dimock, Pennsylvania

At this site we met the operations manager (as pictured below) who took a half hour out of his busy schedule to answer questions about this specific well which will have multiple laterals, each with up to 12,000+ runs from the surface. The site was impeccable and views from the hilltop pad were spectacular.

Operations Manager

Operations Manager

View from the well site

View from the well site

We then stopped at a well about to be hydraulically fractured.

Another view, Dimock, Pennsylvania

Another view, Dimock, Pennsylvania

Again with a beautiful view with minimal disruption. All told, we saw about 20 pads in various stages of activity including completion. Truck traffic was sporadic and unobtrusive on well-maintained/repaired roads. We saw no residential “for sale” signs, but many had new buildings, additions, and improvements.  Cows, horses and humans were alive and well. Even during our visit to (and interview with a resident of) Carter Road, we saw only one “No Drill/No Spill” lawn sign. Instead, we saw dozens of “Dimock Proud” signs.  A “story from hell, aka Pennsylvania?” Hardly!

Finally, this is my recent letter to the editor to the Oneonta Daily Star in response to a guy from Walton who tried to misrepresent my point from a quote published when I was interviewed about the recent Siena “Anti-fracturing” poll.

“If anyone (such as Mr. Dungan of Walton) were to read my entire response in the Daily Star interview relative to the Siena ‘Fracking Poll,’ it would be obvious that I was criticizing the absence of positive aspect reporting of natural gas development in the media as a principal causative of rampant anti-drilling statement.

I stand by my ’10 wells were drilled without incident today’ comment after having spent a day in Susquehanna County last week inspecting drill pads in all stages of activity. Mr. Dungan’s mathematical treatment of raw numbers of ‘violators’ ignores the natural of the violation, the date and number of ‘violations’ associated with a single well, the number of preventative ‘violations’ immediately mitigated without enforcement or fine, the absence of ‘violations’ resulting in public health impact, etc. In fact only a handful of these ‘violations’ could have possibly resulted in a widespread or even localized human or animal health impacts. The fact is that they did not, the regulatory system worked and is being continuously improved. In fact it would not surprise me to see ‘violations’ reports (more ‘numbers’ for the likes of Mr. Dungan and the press) increase in New York State due to the natural and detail of the SGEIS. This is a good thing.

Instead of the Dimock, Pennsylvania portrayed by the anti-drillers as hell on earth I saw well designed, highly safety-oriented facilities and operation staffed by competent, friendly, well-employed individuals. The beautiful countryside is minimally disturbed, truck traffic is sporadic and controlled on well-maintained roads and routes change every few weeks. Local business is brisk, no residential ‘for sale’ signs were evident and renovations and improvements were prevalent. Sorry, no ‘No Drill’ signs, only ‘Dimock Proud’ signs.

I will await regular reporting under the heading ‘Natural Gas Development Benefits Local Community.”

Their tactics will never change…

4 Comments
  • J Howard
    Posted at 18:55h, 20 July Reply

    Way to go Dave. We all hope that all your efforts on behalf of landowners in Worcester will pay off.
    Keep up the good work. We strongly support you.

  • tim kay
    Posted at 23:23h, 20 July Reply

    thank you, a great article showing our county as it truly is, keep up the great work. I also want to extend my graditude for being honest on what you seen here. again thank you

  • Henry Kramer
    Posted at 13:44h, 21 July Reply

    Tours of northern PA gas development areas should be taken by as many people as possible to see for themselves how accurate this article is. This is an evolving industry. To cite problems, even if real, with Dimock’s earliest wells is like judging today’s auto industry by the original Henry Ford’s River Rouge plant. This is a rapidly changing industry constantly improving its techniques and its level of safety for the environment, yet fracktivists dote on the early wells as though the technology was still at that level.

  • atutter
    Posted at 15:24h, 11 January Reply

    “This is an evolving industry. To cite problems, even if real, with Dimock’s earliest wells is like judging today’s auto industry by the original Henry Ford’s River Rouge plant. This is a rapidly changing industry constantly improving its techniques and its level of safety for the environment”

    It’s easy to admit this now, after the damage has been done, yet when the first evidence of this damage was emerging, there was nothing but denial, denial and more denial. So if we couldn’t trust the NG industry then, why should we now? The fact is, the public simply does not trust your industry. Period.

Post A Comment