The Irony of the “Don’t Frack With Me” Crowd
April 25 was a day of irony in Albany.
While Josh Fox made another appearance in a NYS Senate hearing and roaming bands of “Don’t Frack With Me” advocates spread their fact-challenged messages, New York’s Natural Gas Agencies (NYNGA) collectively hosted an educational forum for legislators and their staffs.
After all, what’s the one reason most towns are giving for enacting moratorium against hydraulic fracturing? More time is needed to become educated and learn about impacts and effects of natural gas development. So, NYNGA brought together industry reps, and others, to create a room full of learning stations staffed by experts, not actors. No one who primarily identifies themselves as a concerned citizen, no one with an axe to grind or a personal agenda to drive home, just facts and the science and track record to back them up.
When the pro-industry details were packed up and last-minute packets were delivered to legislators who couldn’t join us, we trundled into the parking garage. Then four casually dressed young people sporting “don’t frack” stickers on their clothes and notebooks stumbled into the elevator, joining us on our short trip. As the doors shut, we were quiet and anonymous, unbranded in this small space.
We reached our floor and, of course, the cart wheel caught in the door crease. One of the no-frack gentlemen helped dislodge the wheel (I wondered: would he have been as neighborly if he knew who we were?). A few steps later, still in the parking garage, a woman in their party lit a cigarette. Yes! A chemically laced, proven carcinogen was pulled from packaging that doesn’t fully disclose the proprietary proportions of its toxic contents.
Perhaps the need for a selfish buzz is OK after a day of advocating for a pristine and risk-free world. Or is this the irony that declares “i’m addicted to big-money tobacco’s benzene and I don’t care if you don’t have jobs, New Yorkers?”
Indeed, it was a day full of irony. And at least one hypocrisy to boot.
Victor Furman
Posted at 22:16h, 03 MayThere are over 4000 chemicals in a cigarette of which 51 of them are known carcinogens. It is illegal to dump over 3500 of these chemicals in a land fill. If you were stupid enough to eat one pack of cigarettes you would die.
Bryant La Tourette
Posted at 03:10h, 04 MaySherri,
“After all, what’s the one reason most towns are giving for enacting moratorium against hydraulic fracturing? More time is needed to become educated and learn about impacts and effects of natural gas development.”
One might agree to this statement if they did not attend town meetings. The towns that have pushed for moratoriums have stated the above quote. But the apposite is fact. I can only speak for my county.
Our county had about 1/3 change over in town board members and supervisors. Of those replacements the first thing on their agenda was moratorium.
Myself and a few other regularly attend town board meetings mainly where moratoriums are on the agenda.
Our county held a training session on comprehensive planning and moratoriums presented by the county NG committee. Only three showed and they were veteran leaders.No newly elected or appointed officials showed!
The interesting part those that say they need more time to learn are off to PA to a meeting from the Park backed CEDLC presentation.
I wish we could say this is about educating our leadership,but unfortunately arrogance and agenda and social exceptance preempts equal education on this subject.
SONDRA BAUERNFEIND
Posted at 14:40h, 22 MayCould it be that the real agenda is financial control and land grabbing ? If the only jobs available are those promoted by the ” powers that be ” and the opportunity for good jobs is limited, then those living in the restricted areas are being subjected to complete economic control which may result in the loss of their real property. Maybe those who realize that the development of the natural gas industry will bring a financial independence to the area which can no longer be controled by those forces who seek to exert the power over the people.