Dryden Landowners Appalled by Decision: DSEC Press Release
Unfortunately, as our anti-gas friends incessantly remind us, the Supreme Court of Tompkins County, New York, ruled in favor of the Town of Dryden and its dubious ban on natural gas development. Justice Philip Rumsey, with his decision, temporarily empowered Dryden’s Town Board to legally strip property rights from its residents without regard to the constitutional, ethical or other implications. This questionable verdict, preliminary in nature at best, has already become a rallying point for the anti-gas political agenda, as the Park Foundation funded Community Environmental Defense Council (CEDC) lobbies for more bans across the state.
Landowner across upstate New York are negatively impacted by the judge’s decision and the actions of the Town of Dryden. Property rights are endangered every day by those who would substitute their judgments, regarding the highest and best use of land, for those of the owners who pay the taxes. Even worse, they do so on the basis of the flimsiest of health and safety concerns. Mere speculation there might be problems seems to be enough these days for local officials with delusions of power dancing in their heads to trash the property rights of landowners. What can be done? Well, the first step is to grasp what’s happening.
A press release from members of Dryden Safe Energy Coalition (DSEC) puts things in perspective. This organization is dedicated to preserving landowner rights and educating the public on what’s at stake. Please share these observations with friends and neighbors after reviewing it.
Dryden Safe Energy Coalition (DSEC)
Press Release on Anschutz Case For release at 7:00 PM, February 22, 2012The Dryden Safe Energy Coalition has read with interest the decision of State Supreme Court Justice Rumsey in the Anschutz suit against the Town of Dryden.
Henry Kramer, attorney and co-founder of DSEC noted, “We are a long way from a Court of Appeals decision that would set statewide precedent. Anschutz has some choices to make. Their options include an appeal to the Appellate Division. Or they could decide not to appeal the zoning issue and instead proceed to a suit for an entire taking of their property interests in the Town of Dryden, valued at five million dollars. So, while the Town may win the zoning battle, it may suffer ultimate defeat if the courts require the Town’s taxpayers to pay for the property rights the Town took.”
“Further, the court found a technical reason to throw out some legislative history of the Environmental Conservation Law, whose preemption provision was written specifically to stop local regulation of vertical drilling. In its analysis that the mining and oil and gas laws are substantially the same the court overlooked a guiding principle of statutory interpretation, that the Legislature’s use of words is informed and that every word and difference is intended to have meaning. Reasoning by analogy from differently worded statutes is dangerous. They are different, not by accident, but for a reason.”
“We caution against drawing too many conclusions from this decision. We are certain that activist groups will seize on this decision as though it was the final word. We anticipated, and continue to anticipate, that is merely the first round in a long and drawn out legal battle. Undoubtedly it will spawn more bans and moratoria as those opposed to energy development seek to prevent any production of fossil fuels in New York State and look to this decision for support.”
DSEC co-founder Tom Reynolds said, “today’s decision means local pocket majorities will be able to create a patchwork quilt of regulation differing about every ten miles and changeable by election every two years instead of providing New York with a uniform standard designed and implemented by an expert agency. If sustained, the decision will probably show that New York is not serious about being open for business and lacks real concern for jobs, the economy, and high paying work opportunities for the 22% below the poverty line in Tompkins County. The message has implications for any business considering coming to New York.”
DSEC co-founder Tracy Marisa said, “the decision allows towns to override any personal landowner choices about what to do with their land. The Town’s ban takes away that freedom and the Town makes the decision for all. Thus the decision is not only about hydraulic fracturing but also represents a loss of personal freedom of choice and vests ever more power in government.”
Submitted by and for verification, Dryden Safe Energy Coalition (DSEC) Henry S. Kramer 1524 Ellis Hollow Rd., Ithaca NY 14850 (607) 275-3653 ConsultKramer@twcny.rr.com or Drydensec@gmail.com
Someone
Posted at 21:55h, 24 FebruaryWHO do these people believe they are to tell people what they can or can not do with THEIR land. Maybe they all should stop paying taxes,stop shopping locally,stop voting for these people who want to rule and start standing up for themselves…..let’s start being America again….LAND OF THE FREE!!!! And STOP being bullied by these morons who have no jobs and to much time on their hands!
M L Keith
Posted at 09:10h, 25 FebruaryThe pro-frackers seem not to recognize that Zoning has been part of local government for a long time. And under zoning law a Town Board has the power to prohibit industrial uses in the town. Frackers want to limit the argument to whether fracking is “safe” but zoning is not limited to controlling unsafe industrial uses. Some towns do not want industry as they wish to preserve the agricultural, rural character of their town. Hence, zoning. Nothing new about that. Thus emotional cries that the town is taking away landowners “rights” are just that – emotional cries. If your town has zoning your ability to use your land is subject to the limitations set forth in the zoning law. You can’t build apartments on agricultural zoned land or conduct a business on residentially zoned land, for example. No other industry gets a “pass” on zoning. Why should the Frackers? The lawyers who are crying “taking” are revealing either a shocking ignorance of zoning law or just pandering to the emotions of landowners – landowners who refuse to understand that in a community that has adopted zoning they don’t have the unfettered right to impose the costs of development on their neighbors. The Dryden and Middlefield decisions merely uphold the rights of Towns to zone. And of course zoning does not in anyway impinge on the State’s ability to have uniform regulations as to how to “Frack”. These are the facts. Learn to live with them.
Tom
Posted at 10:17h, 25 FebruaryYou could not be more wrong. I have written dozens of zoning laws in New York and your contention that a town can, at a whim, wipe out all industrial uses anywhere in the town is just not true. There has to a comprehensive plan and sound reasons to eliminate a use based on health and safety. Moreover, natural gas development is neither a principal nor a permanent use. Also, the idea this doesn’t conflict with uniform regulations having to do with correlative rights that straddle towns is ludicrous. Finally, it is crystal clear certain towns are trying to extinguish mineral rights and supersede DEC, neither of which is lawful.
BH
Posted at 10:30h, 25 FebruaryDear Bill,
I think it’s a little disingenuous for EID-Marcellus to claim to be defenders of property rights.
Why then don’t you come out against Forced Pooling/Compulsory Integration, or Eminent Domain being used to condemn properties in the way of pipelines or compressor stations?
These aspects of the gas-drilling onslaught are massive encroachments to property rights.
I’ve heard you repeatedly lambaste organizations who receive foundation grants to do public service work…. perhaps if we look into the funding of EID (oil+gas industry), then we would understand the source of your extremely clear bias:
EID Rule of Propaganda Number One: Any information which might slow down the onslaught of toxic HVHF gets attacked.
You flip-flop on property rights whenever it fits with Rule #1.
Tom
Posted at 13:44h, 25 FebruaryWe have never hidden where our funding comes from and thanks to people such as yourself, Bill, everyone knows, which is perfectly fine. Most folks, however, are completely unaware of the role of the Park Foundation in funding everything anti-gas; from the research, to the reporting on the research, and to groups such as Common Cause so they can accuse us of doing what they’re doing. Also, we have never taken a position on compulsory integration. It’s simply a fact in New York, and a long-standing one, as is eminent domain for public utilities, which is rarely used anyway.
Bill
Posted at 14:16h, 25 FebruarySorry to disappoint you Bill Houston, but Energy In Depth has never flip-flopped its position concerning natural gas development in New York. You should understand our drive for consistency. Especially being such a frequent guest on our site and in our forums. Quality information is a defining factor of this organization. As far as forced pooling and compulsory integration, you are mistakenly scapegoating the industry again. These are powers granted by the government (state and federal) for the purpose of serving the greater good.
Lets address your uninspiring attempt to claim I’m bias. My family has been in the natural resource business for decades, producing stone and gravel. Needless to say this was long before I ever worked on behalf of Energy in Depth. The stone my family has labored for is used everyday in roads, driveways, foundations, concrete, gardens, etc. It is also used by the state to maintain passable road conditions in the winter. The one thing I see from the environmental community is a constant need to complain and disrupt the hard work of others just because they don’t agree with it. Yet these same environmentalists uses these roads, live in houses, and take for granted the luxury of responsible natural resource development.
Natural gas is no different. It is the product of hard work, responsible development, and a society that takes it for granted. I enjoy my electricity and heat as much as I enjoy my clean air and clean water. Regardless of my current affiliation with Energy in Depth, I will proudly support responsible resource development, including natural gas. Even while hypocritical environmentalist fight against it but continue to enjoy its benefits on a daily basis. Go ahead an argue Bill but I know you are thankful electricity, heat, roads, and plastics, just as much as I am.
Bryant La Tourette
Posted at 16:18h, 25 FebruaryBill, H
Thank you for taking your time and posting your position.
Your view of property rights brings up a good point.
Your position: Compulsory integrations is a taking and a form of eminent domain, the same as what can take place with a pipeline.
Bill, that’s a very easy comment to spew out. Now let’s look at the basics of compulsory integration and pipelines. The above two concerns only occur when 60% of 100% rules giving the MAJORITY the weight; that’s so the MINORITY won’t rule. Kind of like voting. This concept is not new and has worked for over a couple of centuries in this country. I am sure this is a scary concept for some to grasp. The good news for those opposed to American democracy our country does not require an exit visa.
Victor Furman
Posted at 18:13h, 25 FebruaryBH
What would Jesus do ?
Pingback:Another Look at the Dryden Fracking Ban Court Decision | Marcellus Drilling News
Posted at 09:10h, 27 February[…] Safe Energy Coalition (Feb 22, 2012) – Dryden Landowners Appalled by Decision: DSEC Press Release Share this article:ShareTweetRelated […]