Anti’s Plan Another Attack on Natural Gas Industry and SRBC
Democracy depends, first of all, on respect for the law. A few months ago we chronicled how a group of anti- natural gas fanatics led by Alex Lotorto and Bill Huston, among others, deliberately disrupted a meeting of the Susquehanna River Basin Commission (SRBC) and then used their self-created disruption as an excuse to demand another hearing because the people (by that they mean their little group) hadn’t been heard even though they had. It was if someone had burned their paycheck and then sued for non-payment of wages. Such is the nature of civil discourse among anti-natural gas ideologues – shutting down argument to get their way. It’s fundamentally undemocratic and they’re planning to try it again.
We hear Lotorto is organizing a rally as early as 7:30 A.M. tomorrow morning in Harrisburg where he, and others, plan to try to again disrupt the SRBC meeting and stop action on several pending water withdrawal applications from the natural gas industry.
Conference calls appear to have taken place last Thursday evening and last night to coordinate activities and an Occupy Harrisburg training is taking place this evening for whatever disruptions are planned. A memorandum reportedly went out last week inviting a wide range of folks to participate “in the planning to stop the Susquehanna River Basin Commission vote on natural gas related water withdrawals on March 15th.” Among those invited were representatives and/or individuals connected or claiming to be connected with the following groups:

Organizations from which representatives were apparently invited to participate in SRBC meeting disruption planning via a conference call scheduled for March 8, 2012
It is one thing to be invited to participate in something, and quite another to actually participate, so let’s be perfectly clear we do not know who did and who didn’t join the call, but the group is certainly a gallery of anti-natural gas rogues, if nothing else. While rogues are often in style, we somehow suspect not all of these folks are that happy being on Alex’s mailing list, at least not publicly. We now know who he counts among his friends and it’s quite revealing. Here are some of the items from Alex’s agenda (emphasis added):
What are our goals for this week? What does success look like? (To stop the vote, to get Governor O’Malley, Governor Cuomo, and/or President Obama to vote NO on fracking water withdrawal, to marginalize the governors and/or President Obama for voting YES in the public/media, to declare “We’ll Be Back!”)
Our plan for the 15th before/during/after the SRBC meeting (press conference? rally? disruption?)
Recipe for Success – what needs to happen before next Thursday? (Legal observers, bail money, housing in Harrisburg, food, art/signs, call-in days, outreach, press/media, website/Facebook event, etc.)
Alex, has told the world about his plans to go after the natural gas industry on his Facebook page and in community forums. In these writings the intended actions, and intentions of this small group of activists is immediately clear:
Proposals for 3/15 SRBC Action
There are three scenarios that have been proposed for inside the SRBC hearing to me thus far. All of which are fine to make public. None of them seem to conflict with one another and a mix of two or three of them would be possible. Another, separate scenario, would be doing something powerful in the Capitol building such as going to see Gov. Corbett with impacted residents.
As a facilitator and trainer for tomorrow’s direct action training (6pm @ the Quaker Meeting House *1100 N. 6th St. Harrisburg, 6pm-9pm, Harrisburg PA*), here’s how I’d like to handle it:
People who are interested in participating in an action will be asked to come to a consensus on what the action is. If there is a component of the action that would risk arrest, those people who are willing to risk arrest will determine that piece. As a trainer, my goal is to have enough levels of participation that everyone finds a piece that they are empowered by and that accommodates their level of risk of arrest/no risk.
Here are the three scenarios, others are welcome and everyone is encouraged to attend the training tomorrow:
1) A verbal disruption during the SRBC meeting would occur led by people who are willing to risk arrest. Other roles may include applause, taking video, standing and turning one’s back, etc.
2) Standing and leaving before/immediately after the water withdrawal vote, either in silence or while chanting.
3) Standing and turning our backs/turning our chairs around in silence.
For the training tonight, only 21 people are signed up to attend, some of whom left comments to the effect they couldn’t make it. In the mean time, Bill Huston is attempting to have activists “flood” the Facebook pages and phone lines of Governors Cuomo, Corbett and O’Malley, as well as President Obama.
24 Hour Facebook BLITZ to STOP the SRBC! (URGENT!)
If you use Facebook, here is an Easy Action!
1: Like these pages:
https://www.facebook.com/WhiteHouse
https://www.facebook.com/andrewcuomo2010
https://www.facebook.com/MartinOMalley
https://www.facebook.com/corbettforgov2: Post on their wall:
Save the Susquehanna! Dear (Governor or President), since there have been no cumulative impact studies done on the effects of these massive water withdrawals for hydrofracking from this Sacred River, and plenty of evidence to show that these withdrawals and Hydrofracking pose a great health risk, we expect your commissioner on the SRBC to VOTE NO on all new permits. We can live without money. We need these water FOR LIFE.
3: Share this note!
Thanks!
This endeavor began around noon yesterday and with the 24-hour mark having just passed there were no comments referencing the SRBC on any of these pages. That doesn’t mean there won’t be people eager to be arrested at tomorrow’s meeting, but it is telling. This is a vocal minority operating to silence the majority of Marcellus Shale residents who stand behind the development of our natural resources and largely support the gas industry.
So what can we expect tomorrow? Well, we’ll probably see more of the referee shirts from February identifying the protesters. A select few will stand up to disrupt and proudly walk away in handcuffs courtesy of the Capitol Police, knowing the wealthier in the movement will fork over their bail money to let another take the fall for them. Will Lotorto be among the arrested as the “facilitator”? Perhaps, if he was successful in petitioning the Energy Action Coalition to fund his salary for the year out of their grant money back in December; a possibility he wasn’t supposed to discuss publicly, but couldn’t help putting on Facebook on December 12.
Hey everyone, thanks for your support. No decision yet. I’m hoping they’ll fully fund me for the year. I’m not supposed to disclose details for the sake of privacy of the board, but honestly, I hope they see every single name on this status. This should be enough, among many letters that were sent. More updates to come.
Will the SRBC and Capitol Police keep the order? One hopes so. We’d certainly like to avoid the fiasco that occurred when the vote last took place.
BH
Posted at 14:09h, 14 MarchHi Tom,
A couple of corrections.
1) I did not disrupt any SRBC meeting. I was simply videotaping through the duration. I did say something to the NY Commissioner *after* the meeting was adjourned, which in retrospect, does seem like an indiscretion. Next time, I will keep my role more clear. While I may be prepared to be an “arrestable” under certain circumstances, it will not be while I am behind my camera.
2) You put the word “flood” in quotes, however the link you supply I do not use that word. Please try to be factually accurate while you are engaged in ad hominum attacks.
3) “with the 24-hour mark having just passed there were no comments referencing the SRBC on any of these pages.” There are dozens on O’Malley’s wall as well as Cuomo’s. Click on “Everyone, most recent”. Apparently people who post about fracking get banned from Corbett’s wall, and the posts deleted, so that explains the absence there. Obama’s wall as bazillions of posts, good like finding stuff there.
In general, disruptions and Non-Violent Direct Action (NVDA) are completely appropriate in terms of a legitimate Democratic process when crimes against persons and nature are occurring, and all administrative remedies have been exhausted.
Over the past 6 months, I have witnessed dozens of people, some having driven hundreds of miles to attend the SRBC hearings, speaking against these water withdrawals. However, the Commission largely approves most of these permits without discussion.
Democracy Fact Check: To protect the inherent rights of all people (life, liberty, pursuit of happiness), governments are created which derive their just powers from the CONSENT OF THE GOVERNED.
Dozens of people (representing thousands more who cannot attend these meetings) have expressed opposition to these withdrawals, and it is quite rare to hear someone speak in favor of them, yet the Commissioners ignore the public comments and approve them anyway.
Also, how can the NY or MD commissioner vote yes, when neither state has any regulatory framework in place for HVHF?
It is clear the SRBC is a renegade body, which is acting against the public interest. Because there have been no cumulative impact studies done, and there is good science (evidence and reason) to suggest that extracting all of these water, cutting trees for access roads, pipelines and wellpads, and introducing massive amount of toxins into the environment might be a prescription for an ecological catastrophe for life within the Basin.
You can disagree with these facts, which you no-doubt will, since you are paid by the gas industry to promote it, and to attack the opposition.
Your readers should understand the larger context of what is going on here, that we have tried administrative remedies, and we are not being heard.
Did you know the new permits equal an additional 50 Million Gallons of water PER DAY?
http://TinyURL.com/TearsForTheSusquehanna
So let’s compare two events:
1) The SRBC (government body) is allowing the Gas industry to Frack PA, poison the people, water, birds, fish, deer, etc, and remove tens-of-billions of gallons of water from the basin and the hydrological cycle — FOREVER (hundreds of billions of gallons over the life of the “play”)
vs.
2) Some people disrupt a meeting in an attempt to stop a GENOCIDE from happening.
In the big picture, Which is a greater crime?
Nicole
Posted at 15:14h, 14 MarchFirst, Bill, aside from your outbursts at the end, you were disruptive. Your testimony in no way addressed any applications nor did it scientifically discuss why a withdrawal should not be approved, instead you chanted.
Second, 50 million gallons a day is not a substantial amount. The Susquehanna River has a normal flow of about 18 million gallons per minute at Havre de Grace, Md. In one day that’s 25,920 million gallons of water. 50 million gallons is less than 1 percent of the total flow at Havre de Grace in a 24 hour period. The entire flow of the Susquehanna River Basin is 20 billion gallons per day. The entire amount the natural gas industry has used as of December 2011 is 5.6 billion gallons of water. That’s .02% of the total flow.
Finally, your accusation of genocide is paranoid and appalling. What grounds do you have to make such an outlandish statement?
DLB
Posted at 17:00h, 14 MarchBill,
I can allay your fears. Combustion of the natural gas will result in a net water gain for the hydrological cycle. Current estimates of recoverable natural gas in the Marcellus should result in approximately 1.5 trillion gallons of water added to the cycle.
DLB
unclefracker
Posted at 16:07h, 14 MarchI googled this guy Alex and he wears an Arab scarf. Interesting.
unclefracker
Posted at 16:09h, 14 MarchWait til little Alex grows up and realizes how wrong he was.
Mike Knapp
Posted at 16:11h, 14 MarchDisruption is a tool of a desperate person whose narrative has failed to gain traction. “Disruption” being what we call it when adults do it, “temper tantrum” when it’s a child.
Watching those who have gained celebrity by attacking natural gas desperately trying to maintain relevance and extend their 15 minute of fame by ratcheting up their rhetoric is very pleasing to me. It’s a sure sign the battle is over, and that we have won.
Mike Knapp
President
Knapp Acquisitions & Production
Tom
Posted at 17:01h, 14 MarchI agree, Mike!
Victor Furman
Posted at 16:49h, 14 MarchWoW-Fracking WOW Genocide????? where do I begin William Houston
Not being at the meeting your buddies disrupted I cant speak for that, but a you well know I have been at many of your so called Phelmings errr I mean Filmings. Bill your not telling the truth when you say you don’t instigate when behind the camera. First I was a victim of your filming when you shined your lights in my eyes while I was trying to read from my notes at the EPA hearings in the Forum Theater. You were as you were filming chanting woooo hooo as anti’s spoke and that is not just standing behind the camera that is egging on speakers and making your film clips sound effects sound misleading on OTE- TV Bill. So please bag up that part of your statement and sell it to an organic farmer.
Bill you responded “You put the word “flood” in quotes, however the link you supply I do not use that word. Please try to be factually accurate while you are engaged in ad hominum attacks.”
Again Bill Factually acurate… what a joke on your part remember the EPA hearings again…? let me say write this and nothing more to refresh your memory on how you made a local pro gas politician look stupid with the trick of your camera.
“fra fra fra fra fra fra fra fra fra fra fra fra frack” you made him look like he suffered a severe stutter, now how do you suppose that effects people that do stutter… what would Buddah have done?
Bill you wrote “In general, disruptions and Non-Violent Direct Action (NVDA) are completely appropriate in terms of a legitimate Democratic process when crimes against persons and nature are occurring, and all administrative remedies have been exhausted.” Funny I was at Mary Jo Longs presentation last week in Guilford NY and when I stood up and politely said Excuse me Nurse… Your not telling these people the truth about forty of you anti’s stood up out of your chairs and told me to shut up and sit down. You want to disrupt meetings on your side of the coin but without any reaso too they called the state police on me… Fire for Effect Bill cause whats good for the goose is good for the gander!
Bill you wrote ” To protect the inherent rights of all people (life, liberty, pursuit of happiness), governments are created which derive their just powers from the CONSENT OF THE GOVERNED” That works both ways Bill not just when you want it to…. prove that drilling on my land will harm your drinking water and I will join you in the fight against it…
Bill you wrote “Dozens of people (representing thousands more who cannot attend these meetings) have expressed opposition to these withdrawals, and it is quite rare to hear someone speak in favor of them”
Bill I represent 70,000 landowners in NYS who work for a living just making ends meet, most of them are farmers who can not attend these meetings because meetings are held at milking time, a farmer works sun up to sun down 24-7 so you can have your veggies, milk and meat. But you would deny them there right to drill because you and a handfull of retired school teachers and state workers feel that your entitteled to the view (commons as you call it) without compensation for their mineral rights or even helping them with their property taxes. Thank God this is America!
You know Bill I can go on about how NYRAD HAS BEEN KILLING JOB OPPURTUNITY IN UPSTATE NY SINCE 2008, but you won’t listen, nimbys would rather shout then talk.
tim kay
Posted at 17:17h, 14 Marchvery well said vic, thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Nathan Sooy
Posted at 22:32h, 14 MarchIf the SRBC wants a civil discourse, then they will have to give people the respect
of listening to them. And by that I mean ALL of the Commissioners. At the last Commission Meeting only the Pennsylvania representative bothered to attend. If they are not willing to actually sit through people’s testimony, then they will reap the whirlwind when people get appropriately upset.
Nathan Sooy
Clean Water Action, Harrisburg
Tom
Posted at 23:34h, 14 MarchAll agencies use hearing officers and the one who did the last one was extremely fair.
Victor Furman
Posted at 00:18h, 15 Marchreally .Nathan Sooy… your saying listen to me cry or I will have a temper tantrum…. you work for Shaleshock Media ?
Bryant La Tourette
Posted at 00:12h, 15 MarchComparing Natural Gas Harvesting to Genocide?…. I have to use this …… Its way too good!
Man, I have heard so much fear from your side’s theater, but this is precious!!
Bill you try and pick your words carefully and use them to express emotions no fact just pur emotions .But this time you have gone to far…..
Ready repeat after me HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHMMMMMM URRRRRRRMMMMMM
GAAAABBBBRUUUUUU SHHHHHHHHAAA.
Now exhale ……..doesnt that feel good ..Now read this …
THE TERM “GENOCIDE”
The term “genocide” did not exist before 1944. It is a very specific term, referring to violent crimes committed against groups with the intent to destroy the existence of the group. Human rights, as laid out in the U.S. Bill of Rights or the 1948 United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, concern the rights of individuals.
In 1944, a Polish-Jewish lawyer named Raphael Lemkin (1900-1959) sought to describe Nazi policies of systematic murder, including the destruction of the European Jews. He formed the word “genocide” by combining geno-, from the Greek word for race or tribe, with -cide, from the Latin word for killing. In proposing this new term, Lemkin had in mind “a coordinated plan of different actions aiming at the destruction of essential foundations of the life of national groups, with the aim of annihilating the groups themselves.” The next year, the International Military Tribunal held at Nuremberg, Germany, charged top Nazis with “crimes against humanity.” The word “genocide” was included in the indictment, but as a descriptive, not legal, term.
Your comment is, in a word, sick……………………
Victor Furman
Posted at 11:52h, 15 MarchBryant
Nice job with the definition…. Fear and inconsistency in Bills statements are very apparent whenever you hear him speak… Priceless are the tears of testimony at the DRBC hearing.
KJ Rodgers
Posted at 16:41h, 15 MarchWhat is interesting to me is how these individuals obstructed the meeting through chants and breathing exercises, and then wage for another meeting. That they have to train individuals on how their voice should be reflected is enough to raise concerns about. To me, these are not activists, they are a obstruction to the democratic process.
Gov. O’Malley’s initiatives in Maryland are based on extremely high costs for off shore wind. The fact of the matter is, achieving any energy program through his options are light years away from being feasible, not to mention affordable for the state.
Tom
Posted at 10:29h, 16 MarchGreat comment, KJ! Sounds like you know exactly what you’re taking about and I know you do.