Natural Gas Critic Refuses to See What’s Before Her Eyes
![]()
Dr. Scott Cline
PhD, Petroleum Engineering
Part I in a series entitled “Mother of All Spin” about Deborah Rogers’ New York speaking tour.
One of my pet peeves in the shale gas debate is people going around lecturing on topics in which they have no expertise and the media blindly labeling them as experts without checking their “facts”. I see this time and again:
- where a PhD biologist, as part of the lecture, begins talking about fracture stimulation and theorizes how it could open pathways to the surface to communicate with groundwater,
- chemistry professors lecturing on horizontal drilling and fracture stimulation technology
- even lawyers speaking to communities about well construction cementing and casing!
Good grief, apparently having a PhD in anything, gathering non-expert information at anti-natural gas meetings and surfing the Internet now makes a subject matter expert. In this ways myths and falsehoods are endlessly spread and perpetuated.
We can all debate the local benefits vs. the risks and inconveniences of natural gas development, and we do so vigorously here in New York, but we should not mask our “feelings”, or in this case apparently “hurt feelings”, under the guise of expertise meant to misinform the public. This distracts from making important decisions with the best possible information.
A Lack of Understanding Disguised as Expertise

Deborah Rogers
When a media proclaimed “expert” visited the NY Finger Lakes area, and was billed by a local newspaper as “Expert to Discuss Fracking Economics,” I suspected another snookering. So, I attended two of Deborah Rogers “expert” lectures. They were different, but both factually flawed. Within the first minute of each, I was aghast at the total lack of understanding on her primary topic of oil and gas reserves and economics as well as the anti-natural gas bias and falsehoods. The day of her first lecture I found this piece which explained a lot.
I wondered why someone would go out into the public so often to speak on a subject they likely knew nothing about. Well, the speaker gave us the answer at the end of the question and answer session. She stated she had an ongoing feud with an Oklahoma City based oil and gas company regarding their shale gas activities adjacent to her 45 acre farm in the Fort Worth, Texas area.
She said her experience “turned me into an activist!” Now that might be a story worth sharing as long as both sides of the story was told. But, instead, she inexplicably concentrated on natural gas reserves and economics. She embarrassed herself in front of those who knew better and likely deceived many in the audience who didn’t. Her presentation can best be characterized as a collection of out-of-context, unexplained and incomplete clips from the news and her own misunderstood conversations with some in the industry. It was all very much in the style of, and often taken from the outrageously inaccurate New York Times article entitled “Insiders Sound an Alarm Amid a Natural Gas Rush” which has been thoroughly discredited.
It seemed her dominant, and underlying, theme is that there is a conspiracy to scam investors by lying about natural gas abundance and making America dependent on natural gas by driving down prices temporarily and coercing us to convert new uses for natural gas. She supposes then, when the overestimated wells “fall on their face,” prices will rise and we will all have to pay up to the evil companies and be left with an environmental wasteland. She never addresses the conflict this presents with her other idea that exports, which would require vast abundance to justify infrastructure, have always been the gas company’s “end game.”
Ms Rogers complained bitterly at the first meeting that she has been unfairly discredited by many in the oil and gas industry and such unfair accusations were more an attack on her character, and background, than they were substantive criticisms of her work. I don’t think that’s true but, in the spirit of fairness, let me examine Ms. Rogers’s presentation content and comment based on my 30 years of experience in the oil and gas business as a geologist, geophysicist, petroleum engineer, finance professor, financial analyst and valuation professional. There are just so many things to correct in what she had to say.
Falling Prices or Failing Facts?
There is no doubt natural gas prices dipping to $2.20 per thousand cubic feet (mcf), have limited the pace of new exploration in many shale plays. But, to infer prior exploration was a scam of some sort is disingenuous at best. I don’t know of anyone that could have predicted this price collapse and it does not infer anything about wells developed in the past during higher gas prices or the overstating the resource abundance.
Ms. Rogers starts out by saying recent USGS and EIA resource estimates show the industry is inflating reserves and points to the fact the Energy Information Administration (EIA) lowered its Marcellus resource estimates to 141 trillion cubic feet (TCF) based on an August, 2011, announcement that USGS Marcellus resource estimates were 84 trillion cubic feet TCF. She claims this means that industry Marcellus estimates of 400+ TCF are overinflated.
This may sound good on the surface but it’s not the whole story and someone experienced would know that. First of all, USGS resource estimates, although less than EIA and industry, were increased from their prior estimates of only 1.9 TCF. Furthermore, it is commonly accepted that USGS resource estimates are far too low. I wrote a criticism and explanation of this in the Independent Oil and Gas Association of New York’s spring newsletter pointing out that USGS just doesn’t have sufficient data to work with and is always using data that is already out-of-date by the time they publish their results.
Dr. Terry Engelder, Penn State professor and widely recognized as the most knowledgeable Marcellus scientist was also quoted in the January 28, 2012 New York Times editorial entitled “New Report by Agency Lowers Estimates of Natural Gas” as saying he stood behind his previous 489 TCF P-50 estimates. And, just this past week, two studies were released at a Penn State conference confirming resource estimates far above USGS amounts.
I think it is fair to say the natural gas industry doesn’t take USGS estimates seriously and is moving forward with plans based on its own assessment of the enormous resource potential and ever improving extraction technology.
All the Gas Down There?
It doesn’t appear Ms. Rogers even understands what a resource estimate means. When talking about the difference between reserves and resource estimates, she stated, at the first meeting I attended, that resource estimates were “all of the gas down there.”
This is totally false and I corrected her. When USGS spoke about resource estimates they were talking about recoverable natural gas with existing technology. In fact, shale gas resource estimates typically back into volumetric calculations of only 10-20% of gas in place. This is a very conservative assessment and it is virtually certain to increase dramatically over time with increasing technology. Extraction ability is continually increasing and a primary reason the reservoir engineering profession coined the term “reserve creep” or the prevalent tendency for reserves to increase over time.
When I mentioned this to Ms. Rogers she simply dismissed it by saying industry “always says that.” Well, they say it because it’s true! One simply needs to compare the decline curves for shale gas wells drilled a few years ago to the ones drilled today! I’ve seen the evidence myself and it’s clear that dramatic increases in ultimate recoveries over time are occurring. Readers can see some examples for themselves by visiting the websites of many companies that have published decline curves showing this increasing reserve trend over time. For an example, here’s an illustration of the dramatic year-over-year increase in productivity of Range’s shale gas wells from 2006-2010. This is remarkable and getting better all the time!

Natural Gas Yield Curves Improve Over Time
That there is vast abundance of shale gas resource, with a multi-generational supply, is not even a debatable issue. The question whether or not we have a 100 year supply (at current rates) of total domestic natural gas resources may soon turn to whether or not our total domestic natural gas resource is instead a 200 year supply as extraction technology knowledge improves and as we find new promising geologic formations as we drill the shale wells. Here’s a little secret – we already have! More to come …
Dr. Cline holds s a BS in geological science from Penn State, and both MS and PhD in petroleum engineering from University of Oklahoma and an MBA. He began his career in 1976 for Gulf Oil Corporation (now Chevron) and later worked as geophysicist, geologist, petroleum engineer, and senior manager for several other oil and gas companies based in Houston and Oklahoma City. He currently lives in the Finger Lakes region of NY and consults to the oil and gas industry. He also teaches corporate finance and is an accredited business valuation specialist. He was involved in the early study and implementation of horizontal drilling , published on a wide range of oil and gas topics and his research interests include horizontal drilling in fractured reservoirs, well construction and design, reservoir simulation, fluid flow in porous media, oil and gas valuation, reserve and resource estimation, and unitization matters. His PhD dissertation was on decline curve analysis of horizontal and vertical wells in fractured reservoirs. He has recently served as subject matter expert at the US EPA technical sessions on well construction and hydraulic fracturing in Arlington, VA, the Quebec’s Office of Public Hearings on the Environment (BAPE) in regard to formulating oil and gas regulation in Quebec and testified before the NY State Assembly Energy and Environmental Committees on hydraulic fracturing.
Pingback:Scott Cline Starts "Mother of All Spin" Series on Rogers - US Message Board - Political Discussion Forum
Posted at 14:50h, 31 March[…] the EID-Marcellus blog. Check out Part I of the series here (Part II will appear tomorrow, etc.): Natural Gas Critic Refuses to See What's Before Her Eyes | Energy In Depth – Northeast Marcell… Great […]
Concerned Scientist
Posted at 07:52h, 01 April“One of my pet peeves in the shale gas debate is people going around lecturing on topics in which they have no expertise and the media blindly labeling them as experts without checking their “facts”. ”
I couldn’t agree more. Excellent post. Good science is one of the big losers here.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 13:13h, 01 AprilDear Concerned Scientist,
You’re absolutely right. “Good science is one of the big losers here.” Unfortunately neither “concerned scientist–who doesn’t apparently have the personal fortitude to state her/his name and credentials–nor Professor Cline–who, like Terry Engelder–is an apologist neither for truth nor the public welfare, but rather exploits his credentials to ends inconsistent with his academic position–represent good science.
There is simply no credible doubt that, while it may not be an explicitly orchestrated conspiracy to profit handsomely from shale plays–fracking, including all of its associated industries–that the “dip” in gas prices benefits the natural gas industry in the long run by encouraging, for example, the conversion of coal plants or other large coal-powered industries to natural gas. Lower the price, create the demand. Then raise the price. Moreover, the natural gas industry has all the time in the world since the vast majority of natural gas extraction is destined for foreign ports on the world market–where the price is already inflated and rising.
Most importantly of all, however, is that Professor Cline (parroting Terry Engelder) simply ignores the massive and increasing evidence of environmental damage accruing to fracking–including the incident just this past week at the Lathrop Station off PA route 29. Contrary to what industry representatives like Helen Humphreys would have us believe, such incidents are neither rare nor are they benign. Indeed, given the irreparable damage to water and to air–necessary conditions for human life, they demonstrate all too clearly that the natural gas industry is willing to brook what amounts to genocide for the sake of profiteering. Genocide–because these representatives cannot fail to know the dangers of the fracking process, the compressor stations, and the transmission lines (evidence the industry clearly knows–or it would not go to such great lengths to suppress public access to damaging information and would not work so hard to write laws favorable to them–and then conceal this fact).
Finally, last week EID’s Tom Shepstone appeared at a forum on fracking at my university (sponsored by the Green Campus Initiative), Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania–and he tried to promote the simply absurd argument that fracking would actually improve water quality in Pennsylvania by encouraging water testing. Such reasoning is not merely ridiculous in its face, but a clear signal that the industry really believes it can pollute without repercussion–and that private citizens will simply not be able to win lawsuits against them for the contamination of their wells. Look at what happened at Dimock–with virtually no significant penalty for Cabot. The BU audience, however, was having none of this insulting rhetoric, and saw clearly that the “good American” doesn’t swallow this hornswaddle about “energy security,” but has begun to realize that the only difference between Osama bin Laden and Aubrey McClendon is that the former makes no bones about what he was willing to see die for the sake of his ideological aspirations whereas the latter would have us believe that the sacrifice of a life necessity–WATER–is somehow the moral duty of a good citizen.
It is, at bottom, irrelevant how much gas there is “down there.” If getting it out requires the irrecoverable pollution of water, no profit margin can justify its extraction–and there is likely not going to be any technology that can extract the gas all the while leaving the integrity of the environment uncompromised. To Mr Shepstone’s observation that there are always going to be some costs to achieve the benefits of energy production. I say this: Yes–and the costs of fossil fuel production is too high. Where the cost is death–and we can make no mistake about this–the cost is DEATH–the cost is too high.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Professor
Philosophy
Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania
Tom
Posted at 17:16h, 01 AprilActually, Wendy, I received a large number of comments thanking me for coming and presenting that and other arguments. I stand by it and so do hydrogeologists who know how many failing water wells there were in PA prior to natural gas development and how many problems have been identified and corrected through baseline water testing. See http://eidmarcellus.org/marcellus-shale/got-water-tests/6825/ for a great explanation of this, if you’re truly interested in water quality and not just nihilist philosophies.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 23:28h, 01 AprilMr. Shepstone, here is the logic of this argument: Fracking is good because if we didn’t frack people would not worry about their wells being contaminated, and since fracking makes people worry that their wells are contaminated so that they get them tested and then sometimes find out their wells are already contaminated, we, the frackers, have actually done them a service.
The argument presupposes two things–both of which are specious:
1. That the frackers care one whit about well contamination–that fracking is FOR the exposure of previous well contamination. That is, of COURSE, absurd. Fracking is for one thing and one thing only: the massive profits that allow people like Aubrey McClendon to be the highest paid CEO in the U.S for 2010 and that grace him with $400.oo bottles of French wine. There are many ways to discover well contamination–and fracking is certainly not requisite to this task.
2. That people worry that fracking will contaminate their wells sufficiently to have them checked concedes that fracking may contaminate their wells–which is clearly true on the hard evidence–and not just from Dimock. Moreover, you and I both know that getting your well tested for frack chemicals is costly and difficult (a) because ordinary well tests do not include most of the chemical cocktail required for fracking, and (b) because proprietary rights laws insure that we won’t know what all to test for. You and I both know that baseline water testing is grossly inadequate to test for frack contamination, and that it is disingenuous in the extreme to advertise that this is a good for PA citizens. To then point to another EID article–another industry promo (and one I have read)–merely enhances this disingenuousness.
It’s like this, Mr. Shepstone: Claiming that fracking is good for water is like claiming that finding out one has inoperable cancer is good for the patient. Perhaps we DO want to know when our water’s irrevocably poisoned just like we’d like to know that we’re going to die–but the outcome is not changed one whit in either case. Frack water can no more be made clean than can pancreatic cancer be cured. And knowing is cold comfort at best.
What your reference is to nihilism is entirely lost on me–unless of course you just think that nihilism is somehow a central feature of philosophy per se. But surely you could not be that uninformed. If what you’re suggesting is that environmental philosophy is nihillist–that, sir, is simply ignorant.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Tom
Posted at 06:07h, 02 AprilI think you just proved my point.
Also, your unwillingness to concede baseline water testing has any value in uncovering existing water contamination problems that exist throughout PA indicates you have no interest in the facts. You are relying upon your faith in an ideology that tells you hydraulic fracturing must be bad, must pollute, must threaten, etc. and ignoring the reality of what exists. Indeed, you seem to suggest real knowledge about hydraulic fracturing is not possible, and the reality of water quality improvements as a result of baseline testing simply does not exist – pretty nihilistic, actually.
If you don’t trust what we have to say on it, check out this video by hydrogeologist Brian Oram:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OeFP91qL2a8&feature=youtu.be
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 12:07h, 02 AprilIndeed, if your point was that the fracking corporations are about as concerned with water contamination as is the wolf appointed to guard the henhouse, then, yes, I made your point. If your point was that the claim that folks terrified into baseline testing is a consequence of the real threat posed by fracking, then, yes, I made your point again. If your point was that folks may get to find out that their wells are contaminated and that there will be nothing they can do but pleasd with the state for water buffaloes while they discover they can’t get a second mortgage on their homes–much less sell them (and you simply spoke flat falsehood on this point at the forum), then, yes, I made your point.
Excellent. But not, I’m afraid, flattering for you.
I did NOT say that baseline water testing has no value. I said that baseline water testing has very little value with respect to uncovering the presence of frack contaminants. And I said that YOU surely know this. What you and I also know is that the testing to uncover these contaminants is prohibitively expensive for the vast majority of folks–indeed, the very folks who–strapped for money by the recession–are the most vulnerable to the predatory landmen you’d have have at their doors. And you and I also both know that unless these folks BOTH test well in advance of ANY fracking-related activity AND have the very expensive testing done that any claim they make to the pollution of their wells will not hold up in court–especially given the high-powered shark lawyers the frackers can afford. So, please, put THIS canard to bed. It’s about as convincing as your watering golf courses comparison–that is, just absurd on the facts.
Speaking of the facts, you are now engaged in what logicians call fallacy of projection: You subscribe to an ideology that helps you to rationalize the profiteering of the Big Energy corporations in which you have an economic stake. Real knowledge of fracking certainly is possible, and there is more of this knowledge available every day–none of it flattering to the industry. Please read my work posted on Commonsense2 and on Raging Chicken–you will find a bonanza of facts–none of which offer balm to your profiteering worldview. I do not stand to gain financially from ANY position I take on fracking; hence I am free to listen to my conscience. You are not. It’s also you who has embraced the position of the nihilist–rake in as much profit as is possible while it remains possible, and then get out (Well, if you’re smart you’ll get out–good luck finding clean water). Indeed, I am both the realist here–the one who is willing to look honestly and squarely at the FACTS about water contamination–while you bury your head in the sand and ignore the mounting evidence against the industry.
As for Brian Oram, it is beyond ironic that he’s the laboratory manager for The Center for Environmental Quality at Wilkes University. It is, in the first place, not at all clear that his credentials warrant the title Hydrologist–his CV cites an MS in environmental pollution control, but no Ph.D. work, and his website is titled Go Marcellus Shale! Why on EARTH should I take him seriously as a scientist? It could not be clearer that his opinions and argument are pro-gas, and that he is PAID to promote fracking by the gas industry. So, again, please don’t insult your intelligence or mine via the pretense that Mr. Oram is going to argue for anything but fracking–regardless the REALITY of the consequences.
Tom
Posted at 22:06h, 02 AprilBrian Oram is not paid by anyone in the industry or connected with the industry. The fact you were willing to assume that tells everyone everything they need to know.
Brian Oram
Posted at 01:44h, 05 JuneFor the record.
1. Licensed professional geologist.
2. Websites – http://www.water-research.net
I have been educating private well owners for over 20 years – pretty much for free. Prepared a free guide for private well owners – I will be coming out with another free guide this year.
3. Websites – http://www.bfenvironmental.com
4. If you read my posts on any site – you will see that it is always about protecting and helping the private well owners and fact based.
5. Again – not paid by any industry or group on either side of the issue and I mean either side of this issue and I have never asked or received payment to attend an event.
6. No I did not get a PHD was not interested and personally I do not see this as a measure of my knowledge and experience on this issue .
I have taught for nearly 26 years at undergraduate and graduate level and I received by professional license as a geologist and I am a professional soil scientist. I currently teach continuing education courses or courses for multiple Universities and Colleges.
7. I work on the Citizens Groundwater Database for FREE – I am helping two other professors at Wilkes University compile baseline data and helping citizens to understand their testing results, etc. I started this concept when I was running the research laboratory and I think it is a great way to educate the public and track change.
8. I like philosophy – only took 2 courses – my most interesting course was an upper level course titled the Philosophy of Science I took while a student at Wilkes University.
Normally – I would not respond, but I do not know you and I thought a public response was needed to set the record straight. Wish you the best.
Brian Oram
call any time – number on my website
Dean Marshall
Posted at 10:41h, 01 AprilAnalysts suggest that without greater efforts on the part of producers to cut back supply, the major glut will drive natural gas futures further into the basement.
“At the current rate of inventory injections so early in the shoulder season the moment of truth could be arriving for the producing sector even earlier than I had originally expected,” Energy Management Institute analyst Dominick Chirichella said. “At the current pace of injections so early in the season, inventories are likely to hit maximum working capacity well earlier than normal. Simply put unless something significant changes on the demand side of the equation very soon (not very likely in my view) production cuts will have to be announced much sooner than I think the producing sector was planning on.
“The industry is simply going to run out of places to store the unneeded Nat Gas sometime during the next 5 to 6 months. With the market in a classic glut it actually surprises me that the price of Nat Gas is not already below the $2/mmbtu level.”
“Despite the passivity of more production cuts, we could be getting ready for an epic collapse,” PFGBest analyst Phil Flynn said
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 11:49h, 01 AprilIt must first be pointed out that, like Terry Engelder of Penn State, Professor Cline comes to this discussion having already compromised his academic integrity through the use of his academic credentials to ends aimed not at either truth or the promotion of the public good
Tom
Posted at 11:55h, 01 AprilSo, only someone whose research is paid for by the Park Foundation counts, right? You know better.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 13:34h, 01 AprilHI Tom–please accept my apology. This comment was actually incomplete due to an electronic snafu of some sort. Please refer to the much longer post awaiting moderation for my more complete argument. And, yes, I am quite capable of understanding the implications of the kind of water pollution fracking entails. I know what a carcinogen is, I know what an endocrine disrupter is, and I know why the industry works so hard to constrain the debate to the fracking itself. If the public really understood the implications of the associated industries–the compressor stations, the transmission lines–they’d see that the only accurate description of this industry’s profiteering aims involve words like “genocidal.”
The research that counts is that done by reputable scientists who are not paid by the gas industry. This is NOT Professor Cline, and it is NOT Professor Engelder.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Professor
Bloomsburg University of Pennsylvania
Wendy Lynne Lee
Tom
Posted at 17:18h, 01 AprilDr. Cline and Terry Engelder are both highly respected professionals and for you to treat them this way tells everyone exactly what they need to know.
Victor Furman
Posted at 18:10h, 01 AprilWendy Lynne
Professor Tony Ingraffea (no doubt the only honest expert you reveal) spent 30 years teaching young engineering students rock fracturing science…. and now that it’s coming to his back yard he is a Judist preaching imperfections and such… funny how that works
DACrea
Posted at 21:20h, 01 AprilThank you Dr. Scott Cline & EID for two major things you transmitted: 1. The expose’ on supposed expertise of Deborah Rogers, and 2. The chart near the bottom of your article.
Deborah Rogers visited Watkins Glen for another of her ‘expert’ talks and unfortunately I had a conflict and could not attend to see first-hand. But the “shallowness” of the subsequent local newspaper article told me what I’d suspected, and what you detailed above in your article. She does NOT have her facts straight, and presents conflicting information, which apparently the ‘anti-fracking true-believer idealogues’ cannot perceive nor even question. Dealing with ‘hard facts’ instead of ‘soft concepts with inflammatory rhetoric’ is not their forte.
As to the chart….The improved fracking techniques and gas-recovery improvement in ONLY 4 years as shown in this chart are PHENOMENAL! It renews my faith in the ability of Free-Enterprise Entrepreneurs to make breakthroughs, and then fine-tune a process, where no one else saw even the possibility. I was not aware of real-world-data comparisons like this, so find it fascinating!
If only Obama/DOE had thrown the SOLYNDRA et al ‘stimulus’ money at a technology with really-big economic-impact like this….
paul
Posted at 14:44h, 09 AprilSo Scott; what is an educated estimate as to how long Susquehanna County, Pa. wells will product? Thanks, Paul
Wally Mildew
Posted at 09:40h, 16 AprilI note that Tom seems to like the phrase “that tells everyone exactly what they need to know,” particularly as a way to put the kibosh on a discussion.
Tom
Posted at 19:13h, 16 AprilThat pretty much tells everyone exactly what they need to know about your position, Wally? Care to make a substantive comment?
Steve Barnhaus
Posted at 00:43h, 18 JulyGee, I’m not a geologist, but I AM a scientist, and I’m not too convinced by that graph. What I see in there is largely the increase in statistical accuracy that arises from a larger sample size. The curves of the earliest years may just happen to start the lowest sheerly by chance, because they were derived from just a single well for ’06 and just six wells for ’07. The later years start to converge around what I suspect is the true mean simply because they represent larger numbers of wells. Note, for one thing that they don’t progressively march upwards; 2011 started out lower than 2010, and it’s not at all clear why “2009-2010 Avg” was provided when there are already separate curves for each of those years.
In addition, isn’t it likely that the initial recoveries would be lowest simply because the industry had incomplete data on the location of the “sweet spots”? The more you drill, the more you home in on the best-yielding sections, I would think.
Intuitively, I would be surprised to find that technological advances are made so frequently that they would drive an ever-increasing rise in productivity on an annual basis. Again, I’m no geologist. But can one of them explain to me what specific technique refinements can occur on this timescale?
Moreover, one thing that must be admitted the slope of decline is greater for those later years. Though the initial yield is higher, they are also declining faster. The total area under the curve may be somewhat higher for the entire lifetime of the well, but those drilled in 2009 are going to reach the same production rate as those drilled in 2007 in a couple of years. So the supply chain may not be that much better off for those high initial yields.
Finally, this addresses only one part of Ms. Rogers’s multi-faceted argument. She also factors into the cost-benefit equation 1) the energy required to extract petroleum/gas from shale, and 2) the costs associated with repairing damage to the environment. Note that for this latter point, I’m not talking about the abstract “damage” that people assign to subjective qualities such as “peace of mind” or “aesthetic value.” I mean the real costs in repairs, recompense, and fines that the industry must pay when they get backblow all over some rancher’s angus herd or when a collection pit leaks thousands of gallons into a surface stream. That’s not to mention the compensation that must be paid upfront for disruption to crops, fences, etc., with this strategy of death by a thousand pricks.
In the end, the collapse of stock prices and dividends for companies like Chesapeake and Quicksilver pretty much tells everyone exactly what they need to know about the viability– that is, the TRUE value– of shale gas.