Appalachian Basin

BLOCKED Part 2: Vermont Heats With Oil. Montpelier Wants Producers to Pay.

Heating oil has topped a record-breaking $6 a gallon this fall, dropping only after the DOE dipped into the Northeast Home Heating Reserve. This is especially disheartening for families in Vermont, where about one third of homes are heated with oil. With New York still fighting the Constitution Pipeline, more natural gas isn’t coming to the rescue anytime soon.

Montpelier’s answer: use the state’s Climate Superfund Act to make the world’s largest oil and gas producers pay for decades of Vermont’s rising climate costs. In other words, charge the companies that produce the fuel. To be clear, it’s the families who heat with oil that have the most to lose if those costs flow downstream.

How the Climate Superfund Act works

In 2024, Vermont passed the nation’s first Climate Superfund Act. It would require the world’s largest fossil fuel producers to reimburse the state for its climate adaptation costs going back to 1995. The proposal would devise a formula based upon how much oil and gas each company produced.

The machinery is already moving. The state treasurer’s office has hired a consultant to produce a report, due in January 2027 that would put a price on three decades of emissions. Vermont’s Agency of Natural Resources would then have a year to send cost recovery demands to the several dozen companies that cross the law’s threshold. Some estimates put the total in the billions of dollars.

A law already on shaky ground

Before Vermont can collect anything, it has to win in court. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the American Petroleum Institute sued to block the law in December 2024, arguing that the federal Clean Air Act governs emissions and leaves no room for a state to charge companies for them. Two dozen states joined them, and the Justice Department filed its own challenge in 2025. At a hearing in Rutland this spring, U.S. District Judge Mary Kay Lanthier said the law “feels like a tort case in disguise.” She has not yet ruled.

New York’s version didn’t survive. On Aug. 31, a federal judge struck down New York’s Climate Superfund Act on those same grounds, ruling that federal law preempts it and calling the scheme “simply beyond the limits of state law.” Vermont’s law works the same way.

Even Vermont lawmakers have balked at the cost

The state has already walked away from one climate policy once its cost to families became clear. In 2025, state regulators estimated the Clean Heat Standard, a mandate passed regardless of Gov. Phil Scott’s veto, would add 8 cents a gallon to heating oil and propane in its first year and up to 58 cents a gallon within a decade. The program could have cost as much as $956 million over its first 10 years.

Lawmakers never gave the final approval it needed, and regulators closed the case in February. In May, the state Senate voted 17-13 to repeal it outright. As state Sen. Thomas Chittenden, D-South Burlington, put it, the program proved “to be problematic, to be costly.”

Montpelier was right to pull back once the cost to families was on paper.

The Northeast keeps choosing the costliest path

New York has spent a decade blocking the Constitution Pipeline, which would bring more affordable natural gas into the region. Vermont wants to charge the companies that supply the fuel. Neither approach puts a single extra molecule of energy within reach of a family trying to stay warm this winter. That said, something must be done so we don’t keep putting families in difficult positions of having to figure out how to pay for their winter fuel. In Barre, Capstone Community Action says more people than ever are asking when fuel assistance will open.

The federal government has moved in the other direction, declaring pipelines essential to national defense and putting money behind the Constitution Pipeline. Congress has started to do its part, too. On Nov. 9, the Senate voted 73-25 to take up the American Affordability and Jobs Act, the bipartisan permitting reform package. It still faces amendments and a final vote.

Although permitting reform won’t stop a state from passing a law like Vermont’s, it will make it harder for states to block the infrastructure that gives families a cheaper alternative to oil in the first place.

Bottom Line:

Vermont doesn’t need to wait for a judge to rethink the Climate Superfund Act. With heating oil around $6 a gallon and a third of homes depending on it, lawmakers should give the law the same hard look they gave the Clean Heat Standard, before the state sends its first demands to producers and those costs start working their way back to families.

No Comments

Post A Comment