Marcellus Shale

It’s a Bird! It’s a Plane! It’s the Green Grok!

A few weeks back my wife called to say a helicopter had earlier landed in our neighbor’s backyard.  This would have been unusual anywhere, of course — but especially so in a residential area of Honesdale.  Being curious, we crossed the street to find out what happened.

As it turns out, according to our neighbor, his unexpected drop-in guests were from Duke University, of all places — and were apparently in the area to do some “research” on natural gas.  My neighbor, who is unfailingly polite, had given them a ride down to a local restaurant for a meeting.  Who they were, what that meeting was about, and why they had decided to air-drop themselves into our community — he didn’t know and couldn’t say. And neither could we, until we came across a puzzling post on the Internet the other day by someone who refers to himself as the “Green Grok.”

Green Grok's Red Helicopter
Green Grok’s Red Helicopter

The post itself, which appeared on the website of Bill Chameides, the Dean of Duke’s Nicholas School of the Environment, is available here. Reading Mr. Chameides’ post provides all the explanation needed for this strange behavior. According to the post, he was one of the occupants of the mystery helicopter and came back to town a couple of weeks later to continue his discussions.  Chameides is, apparently, the kind of guy who thinks he doesn’t  need anyone’s permission and requires a helicopter consuming about 25 to 30 gallons of fuel per hour to ferry him about — because, well, he’s just so darned smart and Duke University is just so darned important.

Frankly, the Chameides post made my blood run cold until I realized I wasn’t the blue blood here — he was.  Chameides’ condescending remarks were the kind of statements we’ve come to expect from certain parts of academia where political correctness is the first order of every day, arrogance is the rule of the road and special-interest agendas govern and direct the research.  He titled his post “A Visit With Some Folks in Fracking Land,” which pretty well tells the reader what is to follow.  It’s bad enough when our opponents resort to slang terms for a single part of the process to inaccurately and derisively label an entire industry, but you’d think a man who’s the dean of a respected department at a respected university would be a bit more careful and precise with the language he calls upon.

Reading over the Green Grok’s post, I found this description of his meeting with some folks from the Northern Wayne Property Owners Alliance (emphasis added):

We dined with a group of about 20 from the alliance. And they were upset and angry. They said the contract they signed is a model for partnering with gas companies drilling on private land. Among other things, it allows for continuous water testing and other environmental safeguards.

But their plans were frustrated by a temporary fracking moratorium in the Delaware River watershed by the Delaware River Basin Commission while it studies the impacts, a move the alliance is none too happy about. According to our dinner guests, they felt they were being deprived of much needed income by fracking opponents who were, at best, “uninformed.”

The group’s website claims that “the safety of hydraulic fracturing is well documented, with zero confirmed cases of groundwater contamination in 1 million applications over 60 years.” I guess the accuracy of that statement depends upon what you mean by “confirmed.” More on that later, but that attitude set up an interesting dynamic at dinner. You see, some of our faculty, including one in our group, had recently published a paper on groundwater contamination near fracking sites in Pennsylvania. The folks from the alliance knew about the Duke study (one even brought a copy with him) and they were none too happy about it. One of the folks at the dinner opined that the paper was an affront to their community and before we published papers like it we should first consider its impact on people. Another allowed that that was all water under the bridge but he hoped that we would be more responsible about what we write in our future science papers.

I can tell you that I bristled at this as well as the notion that anyone who opposed fracking is “uninformed” and I am sure I was not the only one. But our mantra on these kinds of trips is that we come to listen and not debate. We let it be.

The alliance’s fundamental position is that it’s their land, they did their due diligence to protect themselves and the environment, they’re in line to earn significant amounts of money, and no one should be allowed to prevent them from going ahead. It’s a position with merit, after all it is their land. But property rights only go so far. If fracking on their land pollutes the Delaware, which a whole lot of people downriver depend upon, then I’d say they don’t have the right to frack.

Blue Blood Devil
Green Grok Giant

The way this is written, one gets the impression that Chameides left the meeting with my neighbors congratulating himself on his tolerance of the locals.  Moreover, he just can’t seem to help himself with that whole language thing.  He gets in his “fracking” slang wherever he can, as if it were some kind of schoolyard taunt.  He dismisses the challenges to the Duke University study as nothing more than my friends’ complaints about its “impacts on people,” portraying them as embittered folks who just weren’t willing to accept his science.  I don’t think so.  I’m quite sure, in fact, they complained about the selective well testing Duke did and its taking of funding from the Park Foundation to do that organization’s bidding with the study, points he chose to ignore.

Chameides also included a link to the Duke study in his post, of course, and indicated it was a study of groundwater contamination near hydraulic fracturing sites, contrasting this with the “claims” of NWPOA that “the safety of hydraulic fracturing is well documented, with zero confirmed cases of groundwater contamination in 1 million applications over 60 years,” as if to prove NWPOA just didn’t know the facts.  Well, let me channel Warner Wolf here for a moment.  “Bill, if you were betting on this not so clever juxtaposition fooling anyone, you lost.”

Of course, Bill must know by now the Duke study stated clearly “we found no evidence for contamination of drinking-water samples with deep saline brines or fracturing fluids.”  He also knows the truth of the NWPOA statement, confirmed by no less than Lisa Jackson, EPA Administrator.  Finally, he knows, too, the Duke study was equivocal on the issue of methane migration, using words such as “likely” and “might be possible” and even then relied upon data from seven Lockhaven Formation wells to get high methane readings that distorted the average without including any control samples from the same formation.  In sum: the Duke study was deeply flawed and didn’t prove any contamination associated with hydraulic fracturing, despite the Grok’s attempt to draw a connection in his readers’ minds.

He then rhetorically marches off to proclaim property rights don’t matter if hydraulic fracturing “pollutes the Delaware, which a whole lot of people downriver depend upon.”  Bill may have a science degree, but he obviously doesn’t know much about the law, because the burden isn’t on property owners to prove they won’t pollute when they meet the standards, and the standards have already demonstrated it can be done safely.  No, the burden of proof is on those who would restrict property rights to demonstrate the harm that would justify such restrictions and no has been able to do it – not Bill, not Duke, not EPA and not anyone else.

It’s all speculation. The Green Grok surely knows this and, as for his attempts to put a facade on that speculation and give it a scientific imprimatur?  Well, you be the judge.  This is the kind of stuff holding up the adoption of already developed DRBC regulations by politicians who just love demagoguing the issue at the expense of politically unpowerful landowners.  That’s the message Bill should have taken away, but I’m not sure he was he listening that well.

What’s A Grok, Anyway?

This brings us to an essential question – what the heck is a “grok” anyway?  I’m just a farm boy from Wayne County and we never used terms like that growing up here.  I found (well, think I found) the answer at, not so trusty, Wikipedia where it is described as follows (emphasis added):

To grok is to intimately and completely share the same reality or line of thinking with another physical or conceptual entity. Author Robert A. Heinlein coined the term in his best-selling 1961 book Stranger in a Strange Land. In Heinlein’s view, grokking is the intermingling of intelligence that necessarily affects both the observer and the observed. From the novel:

Grok means to understand so thoroughly that the observer becomes a part of the observed—to merge, blend, intermarry, lose identity in group experience. It means almost everything that we mean by religion, philosophy, and science—and it means as little to us (because of our Earthling assumptions) as color means to a blind man.

 

The Oxford English Dictionary defines grok as “to understand intuitively or by empathy; to establish rapport with” and “to empathise or communicate sympathetically (with); also, to experience enjoyment”. Other forms of the word include groks (present third person singular), grokked (past participle) and grokking (present participle).

 

In an ideological context, a grokked concept becomes part of the person who contributes to its evolution by improving the doctrine, perpetuating the myth, espousing the belief, adding detail to the social plan, refining the idea or proving the theory.

May we conclude the Green Grok is so ingrained in his subject he is no longer an independent observer but part of what is being observed?  It would seem to mean a grok is no longer a scientist, but an advocate who pretends to be a scientist.  Come to think of it, there is a whole lot of grokking going on among the anti-natural gas crowd.  And, that part about contributing to the evolution of the doctrine, perpetuating the myth and espousing the belief (as opposed to the facts) – does that resonate or what?  I know what I believe after reading this description, namely that Chameides is fully entitled to call himself the Green Grok.  Indeed, he may be the Green Grok Giant!

Regardless, what disturbed me so much was the exploitation of everyone he talked to in his post, even to the point of using the Mannings to go after WPX for a problem he never bothered to explain is most likely a mechanical issue caused by repeated flooding.  He also described Susquehanna County residents as “blasé” about natural gas development (tell that to the, literally, thousands of residents who enthusiastically participated in the Cabot picnic last year) and then dropped this little piece of nonsense on the table, the same way he dropped his helicopter into my neighbor’s yard (emphasis added):

As for those who claim that you just cannot document that drilling and fracking have contaminated people’s well water, I maintain that they’re either intentionally or unknowingly sticking their heads in the sand. I have a hard time believing that all the water problems I heard about during my visit were either coincidence with nothing to do with drilling or were made up by people trying to make a fraudulent buck. It’s pretty clear to me that at least sometimes — perhaps because of mistakes and/or carelessness — fracking leads to water contamination that can really set a family or a community back.

Imagine what life would be like, having, like the Mannings, to bring your drinking water into the house daily by the jug-full. Imagine the effects to your property value and your economic well-being.

This is after he used this sentence “Despite rumors that the gas company working in the area had been cited twice for violations (in the casings used to prevent contamination and improper preparation for drilling through the aquifer), nothing can be done for the Fallons or their neighbors according to state officials since manganese is a natural component of groundwater.”  “Despite rumors”?  Is this guy kidding?  Does he think we’re all THAT stupid? Does he think state agencies should act on rumors?  Does he think anecdotal evidence is enough?  Does he think his mere assertions and belief (“I maintain …”, “It’s pretty clear ..”, etc.) are justification for action?  Apparently, he does.  But you know what?  That’s bull — “Durham Bull” — from the Green Grok himself.

Follow us on Facebook and Twitter!

30 Comments
  • susan dorsey
    Posted at 18:09h, 04 July Reply

    He obviously doesn’t grok it at all

  • susan dorsey
    Posted at 18:21h, 04 July Reply

    and Heinlein totally grokked this type of psuedo-intellectualism!

    The Oxford English Dictionary defines grok as
    “to understand intuitively or by empathy; to establish rapport with”

    Green Grok by his own admission failed to establish rapport when visiting NEPA

    my favorite Heinlein quote:

    “Being right too soon is socially unacceptable.”

    and that explains why there are so many ignorant college professors studying hydraulic fracturing

    • Tom Shepstone
      Posted at 19:44h, 04 July Reply

      Great observations, Susan!

  • curt coccodrilli
    Posted at 18:30h, 04 July Reply

    Tom,
    Thanks for the expose’ & teaching me about the word “Grok”. I was at that meeting and sat directly across from Bill. He listened politley but chose to continuosley harp on terms like “carbon footprint”, & “the jury is out on fracking” to answer my pleas about property rights and our plight with the DRBC & numerous politicians , eco-illuminati hollywood hypocrites, and ignorant self serving rural agrarianists who treat our lands like their “state parks”. He obviously had many pre conceived notions regarding drilling and was all too quick to interrupt my words. I was shocked when I read his academic dribble as I gave him much too much credit beforehand as I was taught to respect academia. I should have known better when the Duke “team” helicoptered in “Apocolypse Now” style to preach their anti-frack message to the tune of thousands of gallons of fracked jet fuel. In the future I will hesitate when reccomending meetings like this to our membership.
    Respectfully,
    Curt
    PS.. Happy fourth of July!

    • Tom Shepstone
      Posted at 19:43h, 04 July Reply

      Thank you, Curt! Your insights are always on the money.

  • Carolyn
    Posted at 20:50h, 04 July Reply

    Tom:

    Your logic is most definitely an indication of your allegiance. The studies the industry relies on have all been bought and paid for by the industry, so the “facts” you rely on are no better.

    As for your comment about the use of a helicopter and the fuel it takes, do not even attempt to go there. The natural gas industry probably uses far more fuel (of different types) in their quest to extract natural gas. For example, almost every pick up truck that I see on the road that can be connected to the industry has one person in it driving it around. For what do they need to do that? What about the CEO Aubrey of Chesapeake and his extravagant lifestyle on the backs of all of the people suffering because of his gas plays? I guess you will find a way to justify his expenditures.

    As for your comment about improper casing, failure to protect ground water violations, this is a real issue that is not being addresses appropriately, there are many of those violations happening, some of which the industry has ignored. But more importantly there is an ever growing amount of private drinking wells that are experiencing unusual elevated level of substances in their water that were never before there. The levels being experienced are not “normal” or “seasonal”. Logically had it not been for the gas company doing their extraction operations it would not have happened, it is far more than coincidence.

    We all should want to ensure that the fluids used in the extraction process (drilling, fracking, restimulation, surface spills, etc.) will not get in to the drinking water aquifers, now or in the future. Contamination of one farm could mean the potential loss of not only that family and the food source produced by them but many families that might need to rely on that aquifer as a drinking source. From the documents I have been reviewing and the people I have had conversations with the quality and components of the water have changed and continues to change, coincidentally at the same time as the extraction process is occurring. Go figure.

    If the extraction process was so safe than why is it that Montgomery and Bucks County have put a moratorium on drilling until further studies have been done?????? What is making them doubtful of the safety of the extraction process???? Why do I not have the same right?

    • Tom Shepstone
      Posted at 23:29h, 04 July Reply

      I notice you offer zero evidence of your contentions, Carolyn. You simply throw assertions out there and hope some of them will develop legs. Your “data” is of the same quality as the Green Grok’s, all speculative and undocumented.

      • FS Blank
        Posted at 13:51h, 05 July Reply

        The “green grok’s” data is neither speculative nor undocumented.
        But I have to congratulate you. You know your readership well. .. and that is what makes you so effective when you bash the PhD’s, the attorneys, the successful, etc. that are anti fracking.

        • Tom Shepstone
          Posted at 16:20h, 05 July Reply

          Obviously, it is speculative as he included no hard data. Also, your “the successful” comment is so revealing isn’t it?

          • Tom Frost
            Posted at 22:58h, 05 July

            As one who applauds your response, in your second sentence, to the classic-suburbanite-scum insult about “successful”, I must note that as a result of my being an “anti” I’ve been “successful” at getting MORE MONEY from the gasmen than you and your too-eager-to-accommodate-consumer-scum sheeple are capable of getting.

    • Bill desRosiers
      Posted at 14:40h, 05 July Reply

      Cabot Oil & Gas is committed to reducing its use of imported fuels. The company has built its own cng fueling station and has already started converting its fleet. Next year, Cabot will look to convert its drilling operations to cng. Many of our counterparts in the industry have also started transition to natural gas. Our suppliers and contractors have also expressed intrest in converting. So enjoy your arguments while you can. The natural gas industry is doing more than you will ever know or want to know to protect the environment and eliminate pollution.

    • Vera
      Posted at 22:21h, 08 July Reply

      thanks, Carolyn, for your reply and good points; The industry has problems with defective casing violations . One of these is the Depue well , no. 8, which has a defective
      casing violation by DEP. This is on the DEP site and I’ve talked to DEP several times,
      and recently this past week, and Depue well site is under investigation since last year and before the methane migration problems in Franklin Forks. Shelley Depue leaves out any references to the violations from DEP on her own gas site and makes like there are no problems there or anywhere, and spreads this misinformation in her video backed and paid for by the gas industry, called “Truthland”.

      • Tom Shepstone
        Posted at 05:54h, 09 July Reply

        Vera,

        For someone whose very name means “truth” you know better. The DePue well has nothing whatsoever to do with the Franklin Forks mechanical issue.

        http://eidmarcellus.org/marcellus-shale/franklin-forks-water-well-likely-impacted-by-faulty-equipment-not-natural-gas/7986/

        http://eidmarcellus.org/marcellus-shale/tammy-manning-victim-of-activist-junk-science/8640/

        • Vera
          Posted at 08:52h, 09 July Reply

          there is no mechanical issue; DEP has not determined that; that is only WPX’s determination without a full screening of the water well. It’s again WPX delivering their determinations , which of course, lets them off the hook, and not waiting for DEP to come forth with their conclusions , since DEP has been investigating the Depue well since the violation of defective casing of 2/15/11 and also investigating the Hollenbeck site for defective casing on the east side of the Franklin Forks contamination since 7/20/11. The Hollenbeck well has a service rig up now gathering data concerning the casing, cement, construction of the well. We will see what comes forth from the DEP when the investigation is done.

          • Tom Shepstone
            Posted at 14:33h, 09 July

            Really? I think you and/or your source are fibbing, Vera. We’ll see.

  • Carolyn
    Posted at 10:18h, 05 July Reply

    I see as usual Tom you avoid the hard questions- how about answering why Bucks and Montgomery Counties are concerned about extraction. I suppose all of the residents of those counties are all “environmental activists” or “anti-gas” as you like to label people.

    • Tom Shepstone
      Posted at 16:18h, 05 July Reply

      That’s not a hard question. Bucks County probably has more anti-development folks per capita than nearly anyplace.

      • Unlikely Hospitalist
        Posted at 21:50h, 06 July Reply

        Not Cooperstown…..

      • Tom Frost
        Posted at 14:02h, 07 July Reply

        There are a lot of “probably”s. Why are your standards higher for your opponents than for yourself about presenting DATA to support a claim?

        • Tom Shepstone
          Posted at 05:44h, 08 July Reply

          Actually, the Green Grok seldom cites his sources while we almost always do.

          • Tom Frost
            Posted at 14:25h, 08 July

            You’re not doing so in this thread. Those of us who consider Bucks County to be a very pro-development cesspool continue to await your data to support your claim that it’s the other way around.

          • Tom Shepstone
            Posted at 05:51h, 09 July

            Really? It took me 30 seconds to find this:

            http://www.davidhanauer.com/buckscounty/sprawl/

            You probably agree, of course, since you’d prefer a world where we all rode around on bicycles.

          • Tom Frost
            Posted at 07:14h, 09 July

            That’s the second time you’ve bashed my cycling advocacy. Thank you for enabling me to rest my case that you’re just another one of those hypocrites similar to the ones in your ad hominem series, your motivations have never had much to do with “bringing a soldier home”, because if they were you’d know that riding around on bicycles can do some, though not not all, of that trick just as natural gas can do some, though not all, of that trick.

          • Tom Shepstone
            Posted at 08:15h, 09 July

            Quite the contrary! I actually admire the fact you live what you preach.

  • Nina
    Posted at 14:19h, 05 July Reply

    Isn’t it amazing the the two most flawed studies to come out on oil and gas development were both done at universities with no petroleum engineering departments and none of the authors have any expertise in petroleum systems. Both Cornell and Duke universities have now been disgraced by association and as EID wrote recently, Ingraffea is now forced to say that his opinions don’t reflect those of Cornell. Guess they are feeling the heat of rouge faculty members performing political science disguised as physical science. Duke researchers are no better and showed an utter lack of understanding of fluid flow in porous media that is the real of the reservoir engineer..not hydrologists that would not have training in the intricacies of deep petroleum systems.

    • JD Krohn
      Posted at 19:44h, 06 July Reply

      best comment in the thread!

  • Unlikely Hospitalist
    Posted at 21:52h, 06 July Reply

    This whole thing is a complete Green Grok of Sh*t.

  • chmesineger
    Posted at 08:16h, 09 July Reply

    The URL ” Duke study” seems not to be working

    • Tom Shepstone
      Posted at 08:35h, 09 July Reply

      Thank you! Try it now, but refresh first.

    • Vera
      Posted at 08:44h, 09 July Reply

      Duke U. came with officials from the University to meet personally people with problems since gas drilling and hear their stories in different counties to see if more funding is warranted.

Post A Comment