Professional Protesters Coming to a Town Near You!
Mike Knapp
President of Knapp Acquisitions & Production
Publisher – Knapp Acquisitions & Production PA Shale Gas Blog
New York state is nearing the end of its ridiculous four year moratorium on natural gas development. Four years of depriving its residents of access to their Marcellus gas, while painfully subjecting them to watching their neighbors just across the border enjoy the great benefits of harvesting theirs. It’s excellent news for just about everyone who isn’t a “fractivist”. But as the situation becomes more dire for these anti-drilling extremists, so too are their actions.

- Courtesy of Independent Oil & Gas Association of New York
The writing is now on the wall, in BIG. BOLD. LETTERS. Natural gas development is coming to New York, bringing with it desperate times for anti natural gas activists. New York is their last bastion of deception. A state with most of its population residing in major cities far away from the gas fields, where it’s easy to hoodwink an unknowing populace into believing the benefits of gas are too far away to benefit them, and that negative impacts will show up right at their kitchen faucets. It’s the only place (that actually has gas) where their “ban drilling” mantra has gained traction. Now, its slipping away. Their false narrative has failed and, as desperate people tend to do, they’ve turned to desperate measures, and they’re shipping in professional protestors from around the country to help.
Having no rigs to protest in the empire state, these out of state activists descended this week on Clearfield County, Pa., not at all far from my backyard. In a futile attempt to disrupt drilling operations (and garner media attention for themselves), a small group of a few dozen protestors piled up debris on an EQT access road and hung themselves up in trees in such a fashion that if a truck came through, it would cause them to come cascading back down to earth, from 75 feet up, most likely to their deaths.
The whole ordeal appears to have been planned by Earth First!, one of the most radical and callous groups of professional activists around. They pride themselves on putting their lives in jeopardy to make whatever the heck point they’re trying to make, and of course, putting the lives of law enforcement and others who have to deal with their sophomoric actions in jeopardy as well. Three of them, including Hannah Morgan, 24, of Hartland, Vermont,(seen here fittingly dressed as a clown, harassing police officers in New York City, and being arrested) Michael Luurtsema, 27, of Elwood, Indiana, and Grace Pettygrove, 24, of Eugene, Oregon were arrested by Pennsylvania State Police. All have arrest records that go back years, and span the country.
Never one to miss out on an opportunity to get in front of a camera, our old friend Alex Lotorto showed up as well. Alex the obnoxious, though mostly harmless kid who has taken to chanting to disrupt SRBC hearings, is taking his childish charade to a dangerous new level, putting peoples lives as risk.
From Enviro Politics blog:
One of the protesters, 25-year-old Alex Lotorto of Pike County, said two activists were sitting 75 feet in the air on a tree platform that had been connected to a cable stretched across the access road. If a truck or machine were to cross the cable and cut through it, the tree sitters would fall, Lotorto said. “Unfortunately, this is the extent we have to go to,” said Lotorto
Endangering the safety and well being of the folks punching their time card out on that rig is no big deal to Alex and his merry bunch of self-indulgent comrades. Thankfully, the good folks at the Pennsylvania State Police were on top of it. They quickly procured a cherry picker, removed the protestors from the trees and cleared the road with a bulldozer. It’s certainly not the first time that anti’s have taken the law into their own hands. Just last year, someone took to shooting up one of our active drilling sites with a shotgun, just feet from the landowner’s home.
It’s an absolute shame that these folks are resorting to such tactics, but make no mistake about it: It’s the beginning of the end. Natural gas has the ringing endorsement of both Democrats and Republicans. Everyone from Obama to Boehner is jumping on the natural gas bandwagon, a bandwagon that is quickly reaching terminal velocity, bringing with it jobs, cleaner energy, and increased domestic security. Those who are opposed to drilling are being pushed further and further to the fringe. And rightly so. Hopefully, the last desperate actions of these folks will come and go without any serious incidents, and they will quietly move on to their next cause of the week…but I wouldn’t bet money on it.
Sean K
Posted at 17:27h, 12 JulyWow, they call this journalism?
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 00:28h, 13 JulyIt’s hard to imagine a more vacuous response to the possible end of the New York moratorium on fracking than Mike Knapp’s. The end of the moratorium is by no means a done deal, and anyone who would like to take an honest look st the benefits of fracking need look only to, for example, the work done on water and his air contamination of Wilma Supra, or the stunningly corrupt political connections exposed by Dory Hippauf, or the ringing condemnation of fracking from beginning to end laid out by Tony Ingraffia. Want to see the benefits of fracking, compressor stations, water withdrawal facilities…truck traffic, carcinogen exposure, community destruction, abuse of the law, corruption of elected officials, egregious abuse of eminent domain, the ponzy schemes of Aubrey McClendon, and a laying out of the evidence that demonstrates just how fracking constitutes environmental rape? Go to Raging Chicken Press, and search Wendy Lee. Frightening even for the self-deluded likes of Mike Knapp,
Nicole Jacobs
Posted at 12:31h, 13 JulyAfter years of study, a revision of regs that will now be the strictest in the country and recent comments from Governor Cuomo, it appears permitting will take place this year in New York. If not natural gas, Wendy, what solution do you have for New York?
Concerned Citizens of Rural Broome
Posted at 10:21h, 26 AugustWind power. Solar power. Geothermal power. It’s the future. It’s now. My 1860s farmhouse is heated and airconditioned by geothermal energy. My electric is produced by three solar arrays in my hay field. Natural gas is not clean. 4 % of the methane leaks from the pipes, the storage tanks, etc. http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2012/02/08/421588/high-methane-emissions-measured-over-gas-field-offset-climate-benefits-of-natural-gasquot/?mobile=nc
and contributes to global warming. We are going to have to go to renewable energy sooner or later. Let’s do it sooner.
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 18:42h, 26 AugustNo one is opposed to renewables but they cannot supply our full energy needs. Only a tiny percentage of homes are heated with them and most situations require public subsidies that are unaffordable. Moreover, what do you drive? What are you typing your comment on – undoubtedly a computer with parts made of fossil fuels. Your dream is just that – a dream. There is no harm in pursuing it and it will clearly blossom over time but the idea we can do it overnight is absurd. Those methanre emmissions you fear are also far smaller than you indicate. Finally, I direct your attention to the news of this past week – that the U.S. has achieve major GHG reductions as a direct consequence of natural gas. You are deny reality.
Mike Knapp
Posted at 15:21h, 13 JulyWendy,
We do this every day. We’re out on the rigs, we’re building and manning those compressor stations. We’re driving those trucks. We’re doing the environmental studies. We’re doing the regulatory compliance. We’ve forgotten more about the impact of natural gas drilling than you will ever know. Your boogie-man nonsense isn’t going to fly here. It might work in your circle of friends, but we know better. We can harvest 1,200 acres of natural gas from a well pad that is 8 acres in size during operations, with a permanent footprint of maybe 10% of that. A few months of operations and then decades of nothing more than a few pipes silently protruding from the earth, disturbing nothing and no one. It’s so clean that you burn it in your house, raw, straight out of the ground, without even having to install a vent. Ask Tony Ingraffea (who heats his home with gas) to start burning coal in his fireplace with the flue closed to test his “gas is dirtier than coal” hypothesis. See what he says.
That being said, gas isn’t perfect… but it’s the best that we’ve got, and its significantly better than what we’re using now. But you keep on doing the bidding of the coal industry, I’m sure Mother Nature REALLY appreciates it, as well as the the mothers of asthmatic kids who can’t go outside because of outdated coal plants.
Tom Frost
Posted at 06:15h, 13 JulyMr. Knapp is, similarly to Mr. Shepstone, jealous that he doesn’t get to drink with Alex as I do.
Mike Knapp
Posted at 15:22h, 13 JulyDrink what, Mr. Frost? If I wanted Kool-Aid, I’d go to Giant Eagle and get it sans your secret ingredient.
Tom Frost
Posted at 18:13h, 13 JulyYou mean like your buddy Cabot, whose rent-a-cop likes to make sure that all of the drinking water at its picnics is of the non-local, plastic-bottled variety, which I refuse to drink when I’ve been ordered to dump out my jug of very good SWN leasehold water?
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 20:48h, 13 JulyYou make an occasional good point and then you star obsessing about this again …
Tom Frost
Posted at 21:32h, 13 JulyI still have plenty of obsessing to do about the Sautners’ brown jug also if you prefer.
Mike Knapp
Posted at 14:40h, 14 JulyIf the Sautners purged their water well like they are supposed to (and have been told to do) then their water wouldn’t be brown. Amazing how none of the other folks in the “affected area” that worked with Cabot seem to have brown water.
Tom Frost
Posted at 13:28h, 15 JulyOne of the things I like about my puppy Fracer is that when I rub his nose in something he misses my point less entirely than you do.
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 15:54h, 15 JulyWe try to get your points, Tom!
Gasser Guy
Posted at 08:56h, 14 JulyMr. Frost
You should become a spokes person for the anti group with lots of press and TV time. It would truly help us in our fight to bring gas drilling to NY
Liz R.
Posted at 17:39h, 13 JulyGo Alex, Hannah, Michael and Grace! Behind you all the way. Mike, you gotta wake up – wishing won’t make gas pollution go away. The whole world is busy banning fracking because there’s an unacceptable instance of problems, not because they’re flighty. If these clowns are “professional protesters” then you’re a gas mercenary :o) btw, that video is hilarious – thanks for the link.
Global list of bans on fracking:
http://www.facebook.com/groups/FellowFractivists/doc/440805319293741/
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 20:47h, 13 JulyNot really. You’ll probably see France actually start allowing it in the near future. Also, the mere assertion of pollution does not make it real.
FS Blank
Posted at 06:48h, 14 JulyI like the title “Professional Protesters Coming to a Town Near You.” Mike, are the paid protesters from EID unprofessional” At least on the anti fracking side, we don’t have to pay people to show up.
Nicole Jacobs
Posted at 13:02h, 14 JulyWe’re not protesters and have never denied we are paid. Those individuals from Earth First! are paid to go all over the country and protest, vandalize, and put their bodies on the line; those arrested weren’t even from PA. “We believe in using all of the tools in the toolbox, from grassroots and legal organizing to civil disobedience and monkeywrenching. When the law won’t fix the problem, we put our bodies on the line to stop the destruction.” http://marcellusearthfirst.org/about Do you honestly condone vandalizing another’s property?
FS Blank
Posted at 20:09h, 15 JulyWhen you speak out at town board meetings and public hearings, that’s protest. Paid protest. When we speak out at town board meeting and public hearings, we aren’t paid.
And we still outnumber the gas company’s hired hands and the few straggling land coalition members.
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 21:25h, 16 JulyNo, there were 3,000 yesterday, all unpaid. Your side has produced anything like that. Moreover, by paid protestors we mean folks from outside the area with no dog in the fight, who wouldn’t know a rig from a windmill. Plenty of them have been recruited and paid to protest.
Tom Frost
Posted at 11:36h, 17 JulyTo those of us who have been explaining the non-suburbanite angle of things a little longer than you have because it didn’t take any EID job offer to get us to jump on the bandwagon, it’s: don’t know a rig from a celltower.
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 22:17h, 17 JulyI was on the bandwagon long before I heard of EID, Tom.
Victor Furman
Posted at 03:05h, 17 JulyFS Blank:
I have been to hundreds of meetings, Towns, churches,VFW’s etc etc etc.
I have never recieved one dime from industry or the landowner groups not from anybody. what you need to realize FS is that the difference between protest and information is the two never seem to go together where the NG debate takes place. The landowners and pro fracers talk science, federal testimony from the EPA, Congress, EPA, DEP and so on. ANTI FRACKERS tell the same old BS about genocide, turning NY into a desert, transgendered babies. and radio active nonsense stories. But I gotta admit to one thing, that letter Kim Micheals sent out postage paid by the park foundation to all of Chenango Counties Residents… That was Pricless, Thanks to her letter 6 towns just this week signed the jlcny resolution putting the job of regulating drilling back onto the state and not their towns .
TYVM KIM!
Thanks to Kim and Bill H for their input…. It sure has been a help to our efforts.
Oliver Henry
Posted at 08:58h, 14 JulyWell from the comments we know what the activists are reading. I am surprised that they can even read. Mostly they quote this or quote that; but never anything that has been verified.
I have done research and most institutions will “duplicate” results obtained elsewhere to VERIFY the results. When the verification goes against what the activist want to hear, they deem it biased and rigged.
What a pitiful bunch of nobodies.
Wendy Lynne Lee
Posted at 14:07h, 16 JulyJust to be very clear: the earth First! protesters are NOT paid…that is a ludicrously false claim, and demonstrates how fully illiterate is Ms Jacobs with respect to her understanding of anti-fracking/environmental groups.
Second, it simply is not a matter of speculation that fracking–from cradle to grave–is massively polluting. That Mr. Knapp has to restrict himself very narrowly to the specific frack of a well indicates only that he is in no way prepared to deal honestly with the fact that fracking is not “merely” the actual fracking of a well, but includes, just for example, the pollutants emitted by compressor stations (now unequivocally connected to asthma), the diesel emitted by thousands of rig exhausts, the waste illegally dumped in forest lands or on farm fields. And this doesn’t account for the immensely destructive damage fracking has made for communities via, for example, Act 13, the industry’s gag order on physicians, Pearson VS. post, the abuse of eminent domain, and so on.
Want to see a little bit of the corruption, the pollution, the greed that is the real fuel of fracking?
http://www.ragingchickenpress.org/2012/04/20/state-codified-avoidance-of-accountability-and-genocidal-profiteering-gag-orders-compressor-station-explosions-childrens-art-projects-and-fracking/
http://www.ragingchickenpress.org/2012/03/17/why-fracking-epitomizes-the-crisis-in-american-democracy-profiteering-and-the-good-american/
tp://www.ragingchickenpress.org/2012/02/15/the-unholy-alliance-of-big-energy-big-university-big-state-my-exchange-with-terry-engelder/
http://www.ragingchickenpress.org/2011/07/01/an-open-letter-to-governor-corbett/
And Ms. Jacobs, THAT you are paid to shill for the gas industry completely undermines anything you have to say about it–you are making MONEY from your promotion. Why on EARTH should anyone take you seriously? Same goes for Mr. Knapp. I, on the other hand, have nothing in this but my conscience–no money, no prestige, nada…except this: I know precisely what I am talking about.
The evidence that “what you do every day” Mr. Knapp is destroying our water and air is mounting…every day. And the language of “harvesting” is especially interesting–if perverse. We aren’t growing natural gas, Mr. Knapp–it is neither a renewable resource nor a benign one. That you’d use such language does indicate the extent to which you apparently have to go to convince yourself that this process is safe…..but it also makes abundantly clear that even YOU know better. Very much like the resort to euphemisms about death–like “passing on”–you apparently need to hide the fact that this process is monumentally destructive of water and air–precisely the opposite of growing things for harvest. “Disturbing nothing and no one”? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! You bet–right up to the surging cases of cancer.
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 21:35h, 16 JulyYour rage is showing again, Wendy? Your self-righteous claim to “have nothing in this but my conscience–no money, no prestige, nada…except this: I know precisely what I am talking about” certainly explain a lot. Would you also mind telling us how it is you seem to write these comments from a Bloomsburg University e-mail address. You’re not doing this on University time are you?
Mike Knapp
Posted at 10:06h, 17 JulyWendy,
Don’t you have to take any English classes on your way to a philosophy degree? Fracing is injecting fluids down a wellbore to FRACTURE the shale. Nothing more. A shill is someone who misrepresents themselves as a disinterested third party, while in fact pushing an agenda. Energy In Depth and the good people that work there to combat your self-promotional hysteria make no such misrepresentation. May I suggest that you spend a bit more time in a library and a little less time harassing Aqua America employees who are just trying to earn a living?
There’s much more I could address in your post, but the readers of this site can spot the inaccuracies and mindless hyperbole just as easily as I can, so I’ll save my keystrokes.
Mike
FS Blank
Posted at 21:23h, 17 JulyAre you kidding Mike? EID’s primary goal is to lobby NY to loosen regulations (the ones that the landowners tout when describing how much they love the land). And every one of these bloggers and protesters are paid for every meeting they go to and for every blog entry. If EID stopped paying you wouldn’t see them around.
Victor, if you have so much “science” on your side, why are you always demeaning the anti-frackers? Anytime I feel like giving the pro drillers a little slack, I go back and read your posts. Usually that gives me fuel for another day.
Tom Shepstone
Posted at 22:24h, 17 JulyVic isn’t paid, nor are the dozens and dozens of other guest bloggers and landowners who show up at meetings. Is the head of the NRDC paid? Is the Catskill Mountainkeeper paid? Is the Delaware Riverkeeper paid? They all are, of course, and most that money comes from extremely wealthy NIMBY elitists who don’t give a hoot about the interests of anyone but themselves. Your self-righteous routine is wearing thin, FS Blank.
Mike Knapp
Posted at 13:31h, 18 JulyJosh Fox has made millions from Gasland. $750K in just one check from HBO.
NRDC’s founding president pulled in over $750K in 2006. The rest of their executives were all north of $250K.
Sierra Club executive directors are making over $200K salary. Their COO makes close to $250K per year.
Invent fear. Scare the bejeesus out of everyone. Promise to fight said fear. Solicit donations. Rinse, lather, repeat. $$$.
Victor Furman
Posted at 03:12h, 17 JulyHere wendy… It works for Vera
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9Vw1DdHXMw